Chapter V.—On Justice and Goodness.
1. Now, since this consideration has weight with some, that the leaders of that heresy
(of which we have been speaking) think they have established a kind of division, according
to which they have declared that justice is one thing and goodness another, and have applied
this division even to divine things, maintaining that the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ is
indeed a good God, but not a just one, whereas the God of the law and the prophets is just,
but not good; I think it necessary to return, with as much brevity as possible, an answer to
these statements. These persons, then, consider goodness to be some such affection as would
have benefits conferred on all, although the recipient of them be unworthy and undeserving
of any kindness; but here, in my opinion, they have not rightly applied their definition,
inasmuch as they think that no benefit is conferred on him who is visited with any suffering
or calamity. Justice, on the other hand, they view as that quality which rewards every one
according to his deserts. But here, again, they do not rightly interpret the meaning of their
own definition. For they think that it is just to send evils upon the wicked and benefits upon
the good; i.e., so that, according to their view, the just God does not appear to wish well to
the bad, but to be animated by a kind of hatred against them. And they gather together in-
stances of this, wherever they find a history in the Scriptures of the Old Testament, relating,
e.g., the punishment of the deluge, or the fate of those who are described as perishing in it,
or the, destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah by a shower of fire and brimstone, or the falling
of all the people in the wilderness on account of their sins, so that none of those who had
left Egypt were found to have entered the promised land, with the exception of Joshua and
Caleb. Whereas from the New Testament they gather together words of compassion and
piety, through which the disciples are trained by the Saviour, and by which it seems to be
declared that no one is good save God the Father only; and by this means they have ventured
to style the Father of the Saviour Jesus Christ a good God, but to say that the God of the
world is a different one, whom they are pleased to term just, but not also good.
2. Now I think they must, in the first place, be required to show, if they can, agreeably
to their own definition, that the Creator is just in punishing according to their deserts, either
those who perished at the time of the deluge, or the inhabitants of Sodom, or those who had
quitted Egypt, seeing we sometimes behold committed crimes more wicked and detestable
than those for which the above-mentioned persons were destroyed, while we do not yet see
every sinner paying the penalty of his misdeeds. Will they say that He who at one time was
just has been made good? Or will they rather be of opinion that He is even now just, but is
patiently enduring human offences, while that then He was not even just, inasmuch as He
exterminated innocent and sucking children along with cruel and ungodly giants? Now,
such are their opinions, because they know not how to understand anything beyond the
letter; otherwise they would show how it is literal justice for sins to be visited upon the heads
of children to the third and fourth generation, and on children’s children after them. By
On Justice and Goodness.
635
On Justice and Goodness.