although he might have done these things, he did not do them, but carried out the act of
treason, so as to merit the curses pronounced against him in the prophecy.
And in answer to the Greeks we shall quote the following oracular response to Laius,
as recorded by the tragic poet, either in the exact words of the oracle or in equivalent terms.
Future events are thus made known to him by the oracle: “Do not try to beget children
against the will of the gods. For if you beget a son, your son shall murder you; and all your
household shall wade in blood.” 3274 Now from this it is clear that it was within the power
of Laius not to try to beget children, for the oracle would not have commanded an impossib-
ility; and it was also in his power to do the opposite, so that neither of these courses was
compulsory. And the consequence of his not guarding against the begetting of children
was, that he suffered from so doing the calamities described in the tragedies relating to
Œdipus and Jocasta and their sons. Now that which is called the “idle argument,” being a
quibble, is such as might be applied, say in the case of a sick man, with the view of sophist-
ically preventing him from employing a physician to promote his recovery; and it is some-
thing like this: “If it is decreed that you should recover from your disease, you will recover
whether you call in a physician or not; but if it is decreed that you should not recover, you
will not recover whether you call in a physician or no. But it is certainly decreed either that
you should recover, or that you should not recover; and therefore it is in vain that you call
in a physician.” Now with this argument the following may be wittily compared: “If it is
decreed that you should beget children, you will beget them, whether you have intercourse
with a woman or not. But if it is decreed that you should not beget children, you will not
do so, whether you have intercourse with a woman or no. Now, certainly, it is decreed either
that you should beget children or not; therefore it is in vain that you have intercourse with
a woman.” For, as in the latter instance, intercourse with a woman is not employed in vain,
seeing it is an utter impossibility for him who does not use it to beget children; so, in the
former, if recovery from disease is to be accomplished by means of the healing art, of necessity
the physician is summoned, and it is therefore false to say that “in vain do you call in a
physician.” We have brought forward all these illustrations on account of the assertion of
this learned Celsus, that “being a God He predicted these things, and the predictions must
by all means come to pass.” Now, if by “ by all means” he means “ necessarily,” we cannot
admit this. For it was quite possible, also, that they might not come to pass. But if he uses
“ by all means” in the sense of “ simple futurity,” 3275 which nothing hinders from being
3274 Euripid., Phœnissæ, 18–20.
3275 ἀντὶ τοῦ ἕσται.
961
Chapter XX