“A certain man2057 came just now, puffed up greatly with his own ability, proclaiming
2055 The Elkesites (῾Ελκεσαιταί) were not a distinct sect, but “a school scattered among all parties of the
Judæo-Christian Church.” They are described by Hippolytus (Phil. IX. 8–12) and by Epiphanius (in chap. 19
among the Essenes, in 30 among the Ebionites, and in 53 among the Sampsæans). We learn from Hippolytus
that, in the time of Callistus or soon afterward, a certain Alcibiades, a native of Apameia in Syria, brought to
Rome a book bearing the name of Elkesai (᾽Ηλχασαί), which purported to contain a revelation, made in the time
of Trajan, by the Son of God and the Holy Spirit in the form of angels, and teaching the forgiveness of all sins,
even the grossest, by means of belief in the doctrines of the book and baptism performed with certain peculiar
rites. The controversy in regard to the forgiveness of gross sins committed after baptism was raging high at this
time in Rome, and Hippolytus, who took the strict side, naturally opposed this new system of indulgence with
the greatest vigor. Among other doctrines taught in the book, was the lawfulness of denying the faith in time of
persecution, as told us by Origen in this chapter, and by Epiphanius in chap. 19. The book was strongly Ebion-
itic in its teaching, and bore striking resemblances to the Clementine Homilies and Recognitions. Its exact relation
to those writings has been disputed; but Uhlhorn (Homilien und Recognition des Clemens Romanus) has shown
conclusively that it is older than the latter, and that it represents a type of Ebionitic Christianity less modified
than the latter by the influence of Christianity. In agreement with the Ebionites, the Elkesites (as all those were
called who accepted the teachings of the book, to whatever party they might belong) taught that Christ was a
created being; and they also repudiated sacrifices, which compelled them to reject certain portions of the Old
Testament (cf. Origen’s statement just below). They likewise refused recognition to the apostle Paul, and ordained
the observance of the Jewish law; but they went beyond the Clementines in teaching the necessity of circumcision
and the repetition of baptism as a means to the forgiveness of sins. The origin of the name Elkesai has also been
disputed. Hippolytus says it was the name of the man who was claimed to have received the revelation, and
Epiphanius calls Elkesai a false prophet; but some critics have thought them mistaken, and have supposed that
Elkesai must have been the name of the book, or of the angel that gave the revelation. It is more probable,
however, as Salmon concludes, that it was the name of a man whom the book represented as receiving the rev-
elation, but that the man was only an imaginary person, and not the real founder of the school, as Epiphanius
supposed. The book cannot well be put back of the beginning of the third century, when it first began to be
heard of in the Catholic Church. It claimed to have been for a century in secret circulation, but the claim is quite
unfounded. Eusebius speaks of the heresy as extinguished in the very beginning, and it seems, in fact, to have
played no prominent part in history; and yet it apparently lingered on for a long time in the East, for we hear
of a sect in Arabia, as late as the tenth century, who counted El-Chasaiach as their founder (see Salmon’s article,
p. 98). See the work of Uhlhorn already mentioned; also Ritschl’s Entstehung d. alt. Katholischen Kirche, p. 234
sq. (Ritschl holds that the Clementines are older than the book of Elkesai), and Hilgenfeld’s Nov. Test. extra
Can. rec. III. 153, where the extant fragments of the book are collected. See also Salmon’s article in the Dict. of
Christ. Biog. II. p. 95 sq.
2056 On Origen’s writings on the Psalms, see chap. 24, note 3. This fragment is the only portion of his homily
on the eighty-second Psalm extant.
706
The Heresy of the Elkesites.