Chapter XIX.—Man Would Be More Unfavourably Situated Than the Beasts If There Were No Resurrection.
In replying, then, to those who acknowledge a
divine superintendence, and admit the same principles as we do, yet
somehow depart from their own admissions, one may use such arguments
as those which have been adduced, and many more than these, should
he be disposed to amplify what has been said only concisely and in a
cursory manner. But in dealing with those who differ from us concerning
primary truths, it will perhaps be well to lay down another principle
antecedent to these, joining with them in doubting of the things to
which their opinions relate, and examining the matter along with them
in this manner—whether the life of men, and their entire course
of existence, is overlooked, and a sort of dense darkness is poured down
upon the earth, hiding in ignorance and silence both the men themselves
and their actions; or whether it is much safer to be of opinion that the
Maker presides over the things which He Himself has made, inspecting
all things whatsoever which exist, or come into existence, Judge of
both deeds and purposes. For if no judgment whatever were to be passed
on the actions of men, men would have no advantage over the irrational
creatures, but rather would fare worse than these do, inasmuch as they
keep in subjection their passions, and concern themselves about piety,
and righteousness, and the other virtues; and a life after the manner of
brutes would be the best, virtue would be absurd, the threat of judgment
a matter for broad laughter, indulgence in every kind of pleasure the
highest good, and the common resolve of all these and their one law would
be that maxim, so dear to the intemperate and lewd, “Let us eat and
drink, for to-morrow we die.” For the termination of such a life is
not even pleasure, as some suppose, but utter insensibility. But if the
Maker of men takes any concern about His own works, and the distinction
is anywhere to be found between those who have lived well and ill, it
must be either in the present life, while men are still living who have
conducted themselves virtuously or viciously,
or after death, when men are in a
state of separation and dissolution. But according to neither of these
suppositions can we find a just judgment taking place; for neither do
the good in the present life obtain the rewards of virtue, nor yet do
the bad receive the wages of vice. I pass over the fact, that so long as
the nature we at present possess is preserved, the moral nature is not
able to bear a punishment commensurate with the more numerous or more
serious faults. For the robber, or ruler, or tyrant, who has unjustly
put to death myriads on myriads, could not by one death make restitution
for these deeds; and the man who holds no true opinion concerning God,
but lives in all outrage and blasphemy, despises divine things, breaks the
laws, commits outrage against boys and women alike, razes cities unjustly,
burns houses with their inhabitants, and devastates a country, and at the
same time destroys inhabitants of cities and peoples, and even an entire
nation—how in a mortal body could he endure a penalty adequate
to these crimes, since death prevents the deserved punishment, and the
mortal nature does not suffice for any single one of his deeds? It is
proved, therefore, that neither in the present life is there a judgment
according to men’s deserts, nor after death.