256 ON THE TRINITY. [dOOK X.
which they will with that will. They know also that they
remember ; and they know at the same time that nobody could
remember, unless he both was and lived ; butwe refermemory
;[tself also to something, in that we remember those things.
^'Therefore the knowledge and science of many things are con-
tained in two of these three, memory and understanding ; but
will must be present, that we may enjoy or use them. For we
enjoy things known, in which things themselves the will finds
delight for their own sake, and so reposes ; but we use those
things, which we refer to some other thing which we are to
enjoy. ISTeither is the life of man vicious and culpable in any
other way, than as wrongly using and wrongly enjoying. But
it is no place here to discuss this.
14. But since we treat of the nature of the mind, let us
remove from our consideration all knowledge which is received
from without, through the senses of the body ; and attend
more carefully to the position which we have laid down, that all
minds know and are certain concernincj themselves. For men
certainly have doubted whether the power of living, of remem-
bering, of understanding, of willing, of thinking, of knowing, of
judging, be of air, or of fire, or of the brain, or of the blood, or
of atoms, or besides the usual four elements of a fifth kind of
body, I know not what ; or whether the combining or temper-
ing together of this our flesh itself has power to accomplish
these things. And one has attempted to establish this, and
another to establish that. Yet who ever doubts that he him-
self Hves, and remembers, and understands, and wills, and
thinks, and knows, andjudges ? Seeing that even if he doubts,
he lives ; if he doubts, he remembers why he doubts ; if he
doubts, he understands that he doubts ; if he doubts, he
wishes to be certain ; if he doubts, he thinks ; if he doubts,
he knows that he does not know ; if he doubts, he judges
thathe ought not to assent rashly. "Whosoever therefore doubts
about anything else, ought not to doubt of all these things
;
\ I
which if they were not, he would not be able to doubt of any-
thing.
15. They who think the mind to be either a body or the
combination or tempering of the body, will have aU these things
to seem to be in a subject, so that the substance is air, or fire, or