THE DIALOGUE AGAINST THE LUCIFERIANS. 333
to the penitents. Is there any indication of
his having said, Let them be re-baptized who
have been baptized in the faith of the Nico-
laitans ? or let hands be laid upon those of
the people of Pergamum who at that time be-
lieved, having held the doctrine of Balaam ?
Nay, rather, " Repent therefore," ' he says, " or else I come to thee quickly, and I will make
war against them with the sword of my mouth." 25. If, however, those men who were or-
dained by Hilary, and who have lately become
sheep without a shepherd, are disposed to al-
lege Scripture in support of what the blessed
Cyprian a left in his letters advocating the re- baptization of heretics, I beg them to remem- ber that he did not anathematize those who
refused to follow him. At all events, he re-
mained in communion with such as opposed
his views. He was content with exhorting
them, on account of 3 Novatus and the nu- merous other heretics then springing up, to
receive no one who did not condemn his pre-
vious error. In fact, he thus concludes the
discussion of the subject with Stephen, the
Roman Pontiff : " These things, dearest brother, I have brought to your knowledge
on account of our mutual respect and love
unfeigned, believing, as I do, that from the
sincerity of your piety and your faith you
will approve such things as are alike conso-
nant with piety and true in themselves. But
I know that some persons are unwilling to
abandon views which they have once enter-
tained, and are averse to a change of purpose ;
they would rather, without breaking the bond
of peace and concord between colleagues, ad-
here to their own plans, when once they have
been adopted. This is a matter in which we
do not force anyone, or lay down a law for
anyone ; let each follow his own free choice in
the administration of the Church : let each be
ruler in his own sphere since he must give
account of his action to the Lord." In the
letter also to Jubaianus on the re-baptization
of heretics, towards the end, he says this : " I have written these few remarks, my dearest
brother, to the best of my poor ability, with-
out dictating to anyone, or prejudicing the
case of anyone: I would not hinder a single
bishop from doing what he thinks right with
the full exercise of his own judgment. So
far as is possible, we avoid disputes with col-
1 Rev. ii. 16.
a Cyprian's opinion as stated in his reply to the Numidian and Mauntanian bishops (Ep. 71) was that converts must be bap-
tized, unless they had received the regular baptism of the
Church before falling into heresy or schism, in which case impo- sition of hands would suffice. The question was afterwards de-
cided against Cyprian's views by the Council of Aries (A. D. 114). which ordered that if the baptism had been administered
in the name of the Trinity, converts should be admitted to the Church bv imposition of hands.
1 For Novatus and an account of the dispute between Cyprian
and Stephen, see Robertson's " Hist, of Christian Church," fourth ed., vol. i. pp. 120-127.
leagues and fellow-bishops about the heretics, and maintain with them a divine harmony and
the Lord's peace, particularly since the Apostle
says : ' ' But if any man seem to be conten- tious, we have no such custom, neither the
churches of God.' With patience and gentle- ness we preserve charity at heart, the honour
of our order, the bond of faith, the harmony
of the episcopate." 26. There is another argument which I
shall adduce, and against that not even
Hilary,2 the modern Deucalion, will venture to mutter a syllable. If heretics are not baptized
and must be re-baptized because they were
not in the Church, Hilary himself also is not
a Christian. For he was baptized in that
Church which always allowed heretical bap-
tism. Before the Synod of Ariminum was
held, before Lucifer went into exile, Hilary
when a deacon of the Roman Church wel-
comed those who came over from the heretics
on account of the baptism which they had
previously received. It can hardly be that
Arians are the only heretics, and that we are
to accept all but those whom they have bap-
tized. You were a deacon, Hilary (the Church
may say), and received those whom the Man- ichaeans had baptized. You were a deacon, and
acknowledged Ebion's baptism. All at once after Arius arose you began to be quite out of
conceit with yourself. You and your house-
hold separated from us, and opened a new
laver of your own. If some angel or apostle
has re-baptized you, I will not disparage your
procedure. But since you who raise your
sword against me are the son of my womb, and
nourished on the milk of my breasts, return
to me what I gave you, and be, if you can, a
Christian in some other way. Suppose I am a
harlot, still I am your mother. You say, I do
not keep the marriage bed undefiled : still what
I am now 1 was when you were conceived.
If I commit adultery with Arius, I did the
same before with Praxias, with Kbion, with
Cerinthus, and Novatus. You think much of
them and welcome them, adulterers as they are,
to your mother's home. I don't know why one adulterer more than others should offend you.
27. But if anyone thinks it open to question
whether heretics were always welcomed by
our ancestors, let him read the letters of the
blessed Cyprian in which he applies the lash
to Stephen, bishop of Rome, and his errors
which had grown inveterate by usage.3 Let
1 i Cor. xi. 16.
a As Deucalion was left alone after the flood, so, Jerome im-
plies, Hilary imagined himself the sole survivor after the flood of Arianism.
3 The advocates on each side could plead immemorial local usage. If imposition of hands was the rule at Rome, synods
held at Iconium and at Synnada had established the rule of re- baptism nearly throughout Asia Minor. In Africa the same
practice had been sanctioned early in the third century, but it
seems to have fallen into disuse long before Cyprian's time.