75. Next, however, with regard to your statement that there is indeed one baptism,2077
but that it is consecrated in three several grades, and to your having distributed the three
forms of it to three persons after such fashion, that you ascribe the water to John, the Holy
Spirit to the Lord Jesus Christ, and, in the third place, the fire to the Comforter sent down
from above,—consider for a moment in how great an error you are involved. For you were
brought to entertain such an opinion simply from the words of John: "I indeed baptize you
with water: but He that cometh after me is mightier than I: He shall baptize you with the
Holy Ghost, and with fire."2078 Nor were you willing to take into consideration that the
three things are not attributed to three persons taken one by one,—water to John, the Holy
Spirit to Christ, fire to the Comforter,—but that the three should rather be referred to two
persons—one of them to John, the other two to our Lord. For neither is it said, I indeed
baptize you with water: but He that cometh after me is mightier than I, whose shoes I am
not worthy to bear: He shall baptize you with the Holy Ghost: and the Comforter, who is
to come after Him, He shall baptize you with fire; but "I indeed," He says, "with water: but
He that cometh after me with the Holy Ghost, and with fire." One he attributes to himself,
two to Him that cometh after him. You see, therefore, how you have been deceived in the
number. Listen further. You said that there was one baptism consecrated in three
stages—water, the Holy Spirit, and fire; and you assigned three persons to the three stages
severally—John to the water, Christ to the Spirit, the Comforter to the fire. If, therefore,
the water of John bears reference to the same baptism which is commended as being one,
it was not right that those should have been baptized a second time by the command of the
Apostle Paul whom he found to have been baptized by John. For they already had water,
belonging, as you say, to the same baptism; so that it remained that they should receive the
Holy Spirit and fire, because these were wanting in the baptism of John, that their baptism
might be completed, being consecrated, as you assert, in three stages. But since they were
ordered to be baptized by the authority of an apostle, it is sufficiently made manifest that
that water with which John baptized had no reference to the baptism of Christ, but belonged
to another dispensation suited to the exigencies of the times.
76. Lastly, when you wished to prove that the Holy Spirit was given by Christ, and had
brought forward as a proof from the gospel, that Jesus on rising from the dead breathed
into the face of His disciples, saying, "Receive ye the Holy Ghost;"2079 and when you wished
to prove that that last fire which was named in connection with baptism was found in the
tongues of fire which were displayed on the coming of the Holy Ghost, how came it into
your head to say, "And the Comforter Himself came upon the apostles as a fire burning with
2077 Eph. iv. 5.
2078 Matt. iii. 11.
2079 John xx. 22.
1060
Chapter 32