For this was the object to be obtained by free-will. And man after his creation receives
a commandment from God, and from this at once rises evil; for he does not obey the divine
363
command, and this alone is evil, namely, disobedience, which had a beginning. For no one
has it in his power to say that it is without an origin, when its author had an origin. But you
will be sure to ask whence arose this disobedience. It is clearly recorded in Holy Scripture,
by which I am enabled to say that man was not made by God in this condition, but that he
has come to it by some teaching. For man did not receive such a nature as this. For if it were
the case that his nature was such, this would not have come upon him by teaching. Now
one says in Holy Writ, that “man has learnt (evil).”2843 I say, then, that disobedience to God
is taught. For this alone is evil which is produced in opposition to the purpose of God, for
man would not learn evil by itself. He, then, who teaches evil is the Serpent.
• • • • • •
For my part, I said that the beginning of evil was envy, and that it arose from man’s
being distinguished by God with higher honour. Now evil is disobedience to the command-
ment of God.
2843 Jer. xiii. 23.
822
Concerning Free-Will.