intend, a believing strongly with such a sort of strong faith or great confidence as is consistent
with continuing still, even in the time of these strong acts of faith, without spiritual light;
carnal, stupid, careless, and senseless. Their doctrine evidently comes to this, both in sense
and effect, that it is a mere duty strongly to believe with a lightless and sightless faith, or to
have a confident, although a blind, dark, and stupid faith. And such a faith has indeed been
promoted exceedingly by their doctrine, and has prevailed with its dreadful effects, answerable
to the nature of the cause. We have had, and have to this day, multitudes of such strong
believers, whose bold, proud, and stupid confidence, attended with a very wicked behaviour,
has given the greatest wound to the cause of truth and vital religion that ever it suffered in
America.
As to what follows in your letter, concerning a person’s believing himself to be in a good
state, and its being properly of the nature of faith: in this there seems to be some real differ-
ence between us. But, perhaps, there would be none, if distinctness were well observed in
the use of words. If by a man’s believing that he is in a good estate, be meant no more than
his believing that he does believe in Christ, does love God, &c. I think there is nothing of
the nature of faith in it; because knowing it, or believing it, depends on our own immediate
sensation or consciousness, and not on divine testimony. True believers, in the hope they
entertain of salvation, make use of the following syllogism, whosoever believes shall be saved:
I believe, therefore, &c. Assenting to the major proposition is properly of the nature of faith,
because the ground of my assent to that is divine testimony; but my assent to the minor
proposition, I humbly conceive, is not of the nature of faith, because that is not grounded
on divine testimony, but my own consciousness. The testimony that is the proper ground
of faith is in the word of God, Rom. x. 17.. “Faith cometh by hearing, and hearing by the
word of God.” There is such a testimony given us in the word of God, that “He that believeth
shall be saved.” But there is no such testimony in the word of God, as that such an individual
person in such a town in Scotland or New England, believes. There is such a proposition in
the Scripture, as that Christ loves those that love him, and therefore, this every one is bound
to believe, and affirm: believing this on divine testimony is properly of the nature of faith,
and for any one to doubt of it, is properly of the heinous sin of unbelief. But there is no such
proposition in the Scripture, nor is it any part of the gospel of Christ, that such an individual
person in Northampton loves Christ. If I know that I have complacence in Christ, I know
it the same way that I know I have complacence in my wife and children, viz. by the testimony
of my own heart or inward consciousness. Evangelical faith has the gospel of Christ for its
foundation; but that I love Christ is a proposition not contained in the gospel of Christ.
And therefore, that we may not dispute in the dark, it is necessary, that we should explain
what we mean by a person’s believing he is in a good estate. If thereby we mean only believing
the minor of the foregoing syllogism, or such like syllogisms, I believe or I love God, it is
not in the nature of faith. But if by a man’s believing himself to be in a good estate, be un-
1493
II. To Mr. Gillespie, in answer to further objections.