mistaken, it is fit they should be rejected; if they be not, they will bear examination. If we be
forbidden to examine their practice, that will cut off all hopes of reformation.”
Thus, in these very reasonable and apposite sayings, Mr. Stoddard, though dead, yet
speaketh: and here (to apply them to my own case) he tells me, that I am not at all blamable,
432
for not taking his principles on trust; that not withstanding the high character justly belonging
to him, I ought not to look on his principles as oracles, as though he could not miss it, as well
as Nathan himself in his conjecture about building the house of God; nay, surely, that I am
even to be commended, for examining his practice, and judging for myself; that it would ill
become me to do otherwise; that this would be no manifestation of humility, but rather show
a baseness of spirit; that if I be not capable to judge for myself in these matters, I am by no
means fit to open the mysteries of the gospel; that if I should believe his principles, because he
advanced them, I should be guilty of making him an idol.—Also he tells his and my flock,
with all others, that it ill becomes them, so to indulge their ease, as to neglect examining received
principles and practices; and that it is fit, mistakes in any particulars be rejected: that if in
some things I differ in my judgment from him, it would be very unreasonable, on this ac-
count, to make a great noise, as though I were bringing in innovations, and departing from
the old way; that I may see cause to alter some practices of my grandfather and predecessor,
without despising him, without priding myself in my wisdom, without apostacy, without des-
pising the advantages God has given me, without inclination to superstition, and without
making disturbance in the church of God; in short, that it is beyond him to find out wherein
the iniquity of my so doing lies; and that there is no reason why it should be turned as a re-
proach upon me. Thus, I think, he sufficiently vindicates my conduct in the present case,
and warns all with whom I am concerned, not to be at all displeased with me, or to find the
least fault with me, merely because I examine for myself, have a judgment of my own, and
am for practising in some particulars different from him, how positive soever he was that
his judgment and practice were right. It is reasonably hoped and expected, that they who
have a great regard to his judgment, will impartially regard his judgment, and hearken to
his admonition in these things.
I can seriously declare, that an affectation of making a show as if I were something wiser
than that excellent person, is exceeding distant from me, and very far from having the least
influence in my appearing to oppose, in this way of the press, an opinion which he so
earnestly maintained and promoted. Sure I am, I have not affected to vary from his judgment,
nor in the least been governed by a spirit of contradiction, neither indulged a cavilling hu-
mour, in remarking on any of his arguments or expressions.—I have formerly been of his
opinion, which I imbibed from his books, even from my childhood, and have in my proceed-
ings conformed to his practice; though never without some difficulties in my view, which I
could not solve. Yet, however, a distrust of my own understanding, and deference to the
authority of so venerable a man, the seeming strength of some of his arguments, together
1741
Preface by the Author.