XIII.
A
Rationale of sleep, of yawning, and of dreams
1636
.
1. This life of our bodies,
material and subject to flux, always advancing by way of motion,
finds the power of
its being in this, that it never rests from its motion: and as some
river, flowing on by its own impulse, keeps the channel in which it
runs well filled, yet is not seen in the same water always at the same
place, but part of it glides away while part comes flowing on, so, too,
the material element of our life here suffers change in the continuity
of its succession of opposites by way of motion and flux, so that it
never can desist from change, but in its inability to rest keeps up
unceasingly its motion alternating by like ways
1637
:
and if it should ever cease moving it will assuredly have cessation
also of its being.
2. For instance, emptying
succeeds fulness, and on the other hand after emptiness comes in turn a
process of filling: sleep relaxes the strain of waking, and, again,
awakening braces up what had become slack: and neither of these abides
continually, but both give way, each at the other’s coming;
nature thus by their interchange so renewing herself as, while
partaking of each in turn, to pass from the one to the other without
break. For that the living creature should always be exerting itself in
its operations produces a certain rupture and severance of the
overstrained part; and continual quiescence of the body brings about a
certain dissolution and laxity in its frame: but to be in touch with
each of these at the proper times in a moderate degree is a
staying-power of nature, which, by continual transference to the
opposed states, gives herself in each of them rest from the other. Thus
she finds the body on the strain through wakefulness, and devises
relaxation for the strain by means of sleep, giving the perceptive
faculties rest for the time from their operations, loosing them like
horses from the chariots after the race.
3. Further, rest at proper times
is necessary for the framework of the body, that the nutriment may be
diffused over the whole body through the passages which it contains,
without any strain to hinder its progress. For just as certain misty
vapours are drawn up from the recesses of the earth when it is soaked
with rain, whenever the sun heats it with rays of any considerable
warmth, so a similar result happens in the earth that is in us, when
the nutriment within is heated up by natural warmth; and the vapours,
being naturally of upward tendency and airy nature, and aspiring to
that which is above them, come to be in the region of the head like
smoke penetrating the joints of a wall: then they are dispersed thence
by exhalation to the passages of the organs of sense, and by them the
senses are of course rendered inactive, giving way to the transit of
these vapours. For the eyes are pressed upon by the eyelids when some
leaden instrument
1638
, as it were (I mean
such a weight as that I have spoken of), lets down the eyelid upon the
eyes; and the hearing, being dulled by these same vapours, as though a
door were placed upon the acoustic organs, rests from its natural
operation: and such a condition is sleep, when the sense is at rest in
the body, and altogether ceases from the operation of its natural
motion, so that the digestive processes of nutriment may have free
course for transmission by the vapours through each of the
passages.
4. And for this reason, if the
apparatus of the organs of sense should be closed and sleep hindered by
some occupation, the nervous system, becoming filled with the vapours,
is naturally and spontaneously extended so that the part which has had
its density increased by the vapours is rarefied by the process of
extension, just as those do who squeeze the water out of clothes by
vehement wringing: and, seeing that the parts about the pharynx are
somewhat circular, and nervous tissue abounds there, whenever there is
need for the expulsion from that part of the density of the
vapours—since it is impossible that the part which is circular in
shape should be separated directly, but only by being distended in the
outline of its circumference—for this reason, by checking the
breath in a yawn the chin is moved downwards so as to leave a hollow to
the uvula, and all the interior parts being arranged in the figure of a
circle, that smoky denseness which had been detained in the
neighbouring parts is emitted together with the exit of the breath. And
often the like may happen even after sleep when any portion of those
vapours remains in the region spoken of undigested and
unexhaled.
5. Hence the mind of man clearly
proves its claim
1639
to connection with
his nature, itself also co-operating and moving with the nature in its
sound and waking state, but remaining unmoved when it is abandoned to
sleep, unless any one supposes that the imagery of dreams is a motion
of the mind exercised in sleep. We for our part say that it is only the
conscious and sound action of the intellect which we ought to refer to
mind; and as to the fantastic nonsense which occurs to us in sleep, we
suppose that some appearances of the operations of the mind are
accidentally moulded in the less rational part of the soul; for the
soul, being
by sleep dissociated from the senses, is also of necessity outside
the range of the operations of the mind; for it is through the senses
that the union of mind with man takes place; therefore when the senses
are at rest, the intellect also must needs be inactive; and an evidence
of this is the fact that the dreamer often seems to be in absurd and
impossible situations, which would not happen if the soul were then
guided by reason and intellect.
6. It seems to me, however, that
when the soul is at rest so far as concerns its more excellent
faculties (so far, I mean, as concerns the operations of mind and
sense), the nutritive part of it alone is operative during sleep, and
that some shadows and echoes of those things which happen in our waking
moments—of the operations both of sense and of
intellect—which are impressed upon it by that part of the soul
which is capable of memory, that these, I say, are pictured as chance
will have it, some echo of memory still lingering in this division of
the soul.
7. With these, then, the man is
beguiled, not led to acquaintance with the things that present
themselves by any train of thought, but wandering among confused and
inconsequent delusions. But just as in his bodily operations, while
each of the parts individually acts in some way according to the power
which naturally resides in it, there arises also in the limb that is at
rest a state sympathetic with that which is in motion, similarly in the
case of the soul, even if one part is at rest and another in motion,
the whole is affected in sympathy with the part; for it is not possible
that the natural unity should be in any way severed, though one of the
faculties included in it is in turn supreme in virtue of its active
operation. But as, when men are awake and busy, the mind is supreme,
and sense ministers to it, yet the faculty which regulates the body is
not dissociated from them (for the mind furnishes the food for its
wants, the sense receives what is furnished, and the nutritive faculty
of the body appropriates to itself that which is given to it), so in
sleep the supremacy of these faculties is in some way reversed in us,
and while the less rational becomes supreme, the operation of the other
ceases indeed, yet is not absolutely extinguished; but while the
nutritive faculty is then busied with digestion during sleep, and keeps
all our nature occupied with itself, the faculty of sense is neither
entirely severed from it (for that cannot be separated which has once
been naturally joined), nor yet can its activity revive, as it is
hindered by the inaction during sleep of the organs of sense; and by
the same reasoning (the mind also being united to the sensitive part of
the soul) it would follow that we should say that the mind moves with
the latter when it is in motion, and rests with it when it is
quiescent.
8. As naturally happens with
fire when it is heaped over with chaff, and no breath fans the
flame—it neither consumes what lies beside it, nor is entirely
quenched, but instead of flame it rises to the air through the chaff in
the form of smoke; yet if it should obtain any breath of air, it turns
the smoke to flame—in the same way the mind when hidden by the
inaction of the senses in sleep is neither able to shine out through
them, nor yet is quite extinguished, but has, so to say, a smouldering
activity, operating to a certain extent, but unable to operate
farther.
9. Again, as a musician, when he
touches with the plectrum the slackened strings of a lyre, brings out
no orderly melody (for that which is not stretched will not sound), but
his hand frequently moves skilfully, bringing the plectrum to the
position of the notes so far as place is concerned, yet there is no
sound, except that he produces by the vibration of the strings a sort
of uncertain and indistinct hum; so in sleep the mechanism of the
senses being relaxed, the artist is either quite inactive, if the
instrument is completely relaxed by satiety or heaviness; or will act
slackly and faintly, if the instrument of the senses does not fully
admit of the exercise of its art.
10. For this cause memory is
confused, and foreknowledge, though rendered doubtful
1640
by uncertain veils, is imaged in shadows of
our waking pursuits, and often indicates to us something of what is
going to happen: for by its subtlety of nature the mind has some
advantage, in ability to behold things, over mere corporeal grossness;
yet it cannot make its meaning clear by direct methods, so that the
information of the matter in hand should be plain and evident, but its
declaration of the future is ambiguous and doubtful,—what those
who interpret such things call an “enigma.”
11. So the butler presses the
cluster for Pharaoh’s cup: so the baker seemed to carry his
baskets; each supposing himself in sleep to be engaged in those
services with which he was busied when awake: for the images of their
customary occupations imprinted on the prescient element of their soul,
gave them for a time the power of foretelling, by this sort of prophecy
on the part of the mind, what should come to pass.
12. But if Daniel and Joseph and
others like them were instructed by Divine power, without any confusion
of perception, in the knowledge of things to come, this is nothing to
the present
statement; for no one would ascribe this to the power of dreams,
since he will be constrained as a consequence to suppose that those
Divine appearances also which took place in wakefulness were not a
miraculous vision but a result of nature brought about spontaneously.
As then, while all men are guided by their own minds, there are some
few who are deemed worthy of evident Divine communication; so, while
the imagination of sleep naturally occurs in a like and equivalent
manner for all, some, not all, share by means of their dreams in some
more Divine manifestation: but to all the rest even if a foreknowledge
of anything does occur as a result of dreams, it occurs in the way we
have spoken of.
13. And again, if the Egyptian
and the Assyrian king were guided by God to the knowledge of the
future, the dispensation wrought by their means is a different thing:
for it was necessary that the hidden wisdom of the holy men
1641
should be made known, that each of them
might not pass his life without profit to the state. For how could
Daniel have been known for what he was, if the soothsayers and
magicians had not been unequal to the task of discovering the dream?
And how could Egypt have been preserved while Joseph was shut up in
prison, if his interpretation of the dream had not brought him to
notice? Thus we must reckon these cases as exceptional, and not class
them with common dreams.
14. But this ordinary seeing of
dreams is common to all men, and arises in our fancies in different
modes and forms: for either there remain, as we have said, in the
reminiscent part of the soul, the echoes of daily occupations; or, as
often happens, the constitution of dreams is framed with regard to such
and such a condition of the body: for thus the thirsty man seems to be
among springs, the man who is in need of food to be at a feast, and the
young man in the heat of youthful vigour is beset by fancies
corresponding to his passion.
15. I also knew another cause of
the fancies of sleep, when attending one of my relations attacked by
frenzy; who being annoyed by food being given him in too great quantity
for his strength, kept crying out and finding fault with those who were
about him for filling intestines with dung and putting them upon him:
and when his body was rapidly tending to perspire he blamed those who
were with him for having water ready to wet him with as he lay: and he
did not cease calling out till the result showed the meaning of these
complaints: for all at once a copious sweat broke out over his body,
and a relaxation of the bowels explained the weight in the intestines.
The same condition then which, while his sober judgment was dulled by
disease, his nature underwent, being sympathetically affected by the
condition of the body—not being without perception of what was
amiss, but being unable clearly to express its pain, by reason of the
distraction resulting from the disease—this, probably, if the
intelligent principle of the soul were lulled to rest, not from
infirmity but by natural sleep, might appear as a dream to one
similarly situated, the breaking out of perspiration being expressed by
water, and the pain occasioned by the food, by the weight of
intestines.
16. This view also is taken by
those skilled in medicine, that according to the differences of
complaints the visions of dreams appear differently to the patients:
that the visions of those of weak stomach are of one kind, those of
persons suffering from injury to the cerebral membrane of another,
those of persons in fevers of yet another; that those of patients
suffering from bilious and from phlegmatic affections are diverse, and
those again of plethoric patients, and of patients in wasting disease,
are different; whence we may see that the nutritive and vegetative
faculty of the soul has in it by commixture some seed of the
intelligent element, which is in some sense brought into likeness to
the particular state of the body, being adapted in its fancies
according to the complaint which has seized upon it.
17. Moreover, most men’s
dreams are conformed to the state of their character: the brave
man’s fancies are of one kind, the coward’s of another; the
wanton man’s dreams of one kind, the continent man’s of
another; the liberal man and the avaricious man are subject to
different fancies; while these fancies are nowhere framed by the
intellect, but by the less rational disposition of the soul, which
forms even in dreams the semblances of those things to which each is
accustomed by the practice of his waking hours.
1636
The
Latin version (and with it several of the Greek
mss.
) makes this the fourteenth chapter. The Bodleian
ms.
gives as its title:—“That our
body is always in motion.”
1637
Life
is represented as a succession of opposite states (
τῶν
ἐναντίων
διαδοχὴ
),
which yet recur again and again in the same sequence (
διὰ τῶν
ὁμοίων
). This
is illustrated in the following section.
1638
Reading
μηχανῆς
with the earlier editions and (apparently) a large number of
Forbes’
mss.
in place of
μηχανικῆς
. But
μολυβδίνης
may be for
μολυβδαίνης
1639
Reading
δείκνυσιν
, as Forbes does (apparently from all the
mss.
and agreeing with the earlier editt.). The Latin
translation points to the reading
δείκνυται
1640
Reading
ἐπιδιστάζουσα
with several of Forbes’
mss.
1641
“The holy men,” Joseph and Daniel, who were enabled,
by the authority they obtained through their interpretation of dreams,
to benefit the state.