derive His source from Him. ‘I live by the Father216:’ but it is impossible to name the ‘when’
of His beginning. When there is no intermediate matter, or idea, or interval of time, to
separate the being of the Son from the Father, no symbol can be thought of, either, by which
the Only-begotten can be unlinked from the Father’s life, and shewn to proceed from some
special source of His own. If, then, there is no other principle that guides the Son’s life, if
there is nothing that a devout mind can contemplate before (but not divided from) the
subsistence of the Son, but the Father only; and if the Father is without beginning or gener-
ation, as even our adversaries admit, how can He who can be contemplated only within the
Father, who is without beginning, admit Himself of a beginning?
95
What harm, too, does our Faith suffer from our admitting those expressions of our op-
ponents which they bring forward against us as absurd, when they ask ‘whether He which
is can be begotten?’ We do not assert that this can be so in the sense in which Nicodemus
put his offensive question217, wherein he thought it impossible that one who was in existence
could come to a second birth: but we assert that, having His existence attached to an Existence
which is always and is without beginning, and accompanying every investigator into the
antiquities of time, and forestalling the curiosity of thought as it advances into the world
beyond, and intimately blended as He is with all our conceptions of the Father, He has no
beginning of His existence any more than He is Ungenerate: but He was both begotten and
was, evincing on the score of causation generation from the Father, but by virtue of His
everlasting life repelling any moment of non-existence.
But this thinker in his exceeding subtlety contravenes this statement; he sunders the
being of the Only-begotten from the Father’s nature, on the ground of one being Generated,
the other Ungenerate; and although there are such a number of names which with reverence
may be applied to the Deity, and all of them suitable to both Persons equally, he pays no
attention to anyone of them, because these others indicate that in which Both participate;
he fastens on the name Ungenerate, and that alone; and even of this he will not adopt the
usual and approved meaning; he revolutionizes the conception of it, and cancels its common
associations. Whatever can be the reason of this? For without some very strong one he would
not wrest language away from its accepted meaning, and innovate218 by changing the signi-
fication of words. He knows perfectly well that if their meaning was confined to the customary
one he would have no power to subvert the sound doctrine; but that if such terms are per-
verted from their common and current acceptation, he will be able to spoil the doctrine
along with the word. For instance (to come to the actual words which he misuses), if, accord-
ing to the common thinking of our Faith he had allowed that God was to be called Ungen-
216 John iv. 57.
217 John iii. 4.
218 ξενίζει, intrans. N.T. Polyb. Lucian.
180
Answer to the question he is always asking, “Can He who is be begotten?