persons, declaring that none such ought to come. See the eighty-first and other questions
and answers, with Ursin’s Latin Explications, and De Witte’s English Catechizings thereon.
Here, Sir, indeed you have the judgment of a multitude in one. Another celebrated book is
Claude’s Historical Defence of the Reformation; in which I meet with repeated declarations
of the same sentiments, perfectly on the negative side of the question in hand, but, I think,
too many and too long to be here transcribed.—The language of some of them I have just
now had occasion to make use of.
As for the church of Scotland, I find they have adopted the Westminster Confession,
Catechisms, and Directory, which debar all ignorant and ungodly persons from the Lord’s
table, and require every one to examine himself, not only as to his knowledge, but also his
faith, repentance, love, new obedience, &c.—In their books of discipline, I observe sundry
passages that appropriate the sacrament to the truly penitent and faithful, as the only proper
subjects. Their national covenant, renewed from time to time, has this clause; to the which
[true reformed kirk] we join ourselves willingly, in doctrine, faith, religion, discipline, and
use of the holy sacraments, as lively members of the same in Christ our Head, &c. And among
the divines of Scotland, I find many in their sermons, sacramental speeches, and other dis-
courses, declaring themselves strongly on the negative part in the question before us, advising
to strictness in admission to the Lord’s supper, renouncing the opinion of its being a con-
verting ordinance, inviting only the sincere friends of Christ to it, and frequently warning
professors conscious of reigning sin and hypocrisy to forbear approaching the Lord’s table.
I might bring much to this purpose from Mr. Andrew Gray’s book of sermons, published
anno 1716; and his sermons printed anno 1746; with a preface by Mr. Willison.—So from
Mr. Ebenezer Erskine’s synodical sermon, anno 1732.—And from Mr. Ralph Erskine’s sermon
on Isa. xlii. 6. and his discourse on fencing the tables, annexed to his sermon on John xvi.
15..—So from Mr. Willison’s synodical sermon, anno 1733; where he sets down a variety of
searching questions (no less than twenty-seven) which he advises to be put to proponants,
and their answers to be waited for, before they are admitted.—The anonymous author of a
Defence of National Churches against the Independents, (who is reputed to be Mr. Willison,)
asserts it as a presbyterian principle, that none have right before God to the complete com-
munion of the church, but such as have grace; and that none are to be admitted but those
who are saints, at least in profession; such as profess to accept of the offers of Christ’s grace,
&c. and confess themselves to be sincere. Mr. Aytone, in his Review, against Mr. Glas, owns
that the Lord’s supper is not a formal mean of conversion, but of further growth and nour-
ishment to those already converted. In the same strain is Mr. Nasmith’s Treatise of the Entail
of the Covenant.—And Mr. Warden’s Essay on Baptism. In a word, I find Mr. Currie (in his
synodical sermon, anno 1732) testifying of the ministers in Scotland, that they are tender
(i. e. circumspect and cautious) in admitting people to the holy table of the Lord; knowing
the design of the ordinance is not conversion, but confirmation; and he observes, that all who
1881
Appendix. Mr. Foxcroft's letter.