But this was at first only true of Spain, and at Rome nothing of the kind was known.
In the Gelasian Sacramentary the Creed is found in its original form.215 The same is the
case with the old Gallican Sacramentary of the viith or viiith century.216
However, there can be no doubt that its introduction spread very rapidly through the
West and that before long it was received practically everywhere except at Rome.
In 809 a council was held at Aix-la-Chapelle by Charlemagne, and from it three divines
were sent to confer with the Pope, Leo III, upon the subject. The Pope opposed the insertion
of the Filioque on the express ground that the General Councils had forbidden any addition
to be made to their formulary.217 Later on, the Frankish Emperor asked his bishops what
was “the meaning of the Creed according to the Latins,”218 and Fleury gives the result of
the investigations to have been, “In France they continued to chant the creed with the word
Filioque, and at Rome they continued not to chant it.”219
167
So firmly resolved was the Pope that the clause should not be introduced into the creed
that he presented two silver shields to the Confessio in St. Peter’s at Rome, on one of which
was engraved the creed in Latin and on the other in Greek, without the addition. This act
the Greeks never forgot during the controversy. Photius refers to it in writing to the Patriarch
of Acquileia. About two centuries later St. Peter Damian220 mentions them as still in place;
and about two centuries later on, Veccur, Patriarch of Constantinople, declares they hung
there still.221
It was not till 1014 that for the first time the interpolated creed was used at mass with
the sanction of the Pope. In that year Benedict VIII. acceded to the urgent request of Henry
II. of Germany and so the papal authority was forced to yield, and the silver shields have
disappeared from St. Peter’s.
3. Nothing could be clearer than that the theologians of the West never had any idea
of teaching a double source of the Godhead. The doctrine of the Divine Monarchy was always
intended to be preserved, and while in the heat of the controversy sometimes expressions
highly dangerous, or at least clearly inaccurate, may have been used, yet the intention must
be judged from the prevailing teaching of the approved theologians. And what this was is
evident from the definition of the Council of Florence, which, while indeed it was not received
by the Eastern Church, and therefore cannot be accepted as an authoritative exposition of
215 Muratorius. Ord. Rom., Tom. I., col. 541.
216 Mabillon. Mus. Ital., Tom. I., p. 313 and p. 376.
217 Labbe and Cossart. Concilia, Tom. vij., col. 1194.
218 Capit. Reg. Franc., Tom. I., p. 483.
219 Fleury. Hist. Eccl., Liv. xlv., chap. 48.
220 Pet. Damian. Opusc., xxxviij.
221 Leo Allat. Græc. Orthod., Tom. I., p. 173.
334
Historical Excursus on the Introduction into the Creed of the Words “and…