§2. He then ingeniously shows that the generation of the Son is not according to the phrase
of Eunomius, “The Father begat Him at that time when He chose, and not before:” but that
the Son, being the fulness of all that is good and excellent, is always contemplated in the
Father; using for this demonstration the support of Eunomius’ own arguments.
However, though there is no interval between them, he does not admit that their com-
munion is immediate and intimate, but condescends to the measure of our knowledge, and
213
converses with us in human phrase as one of ourselves, himself quietly confessing the im-
potence of reasoning and taking refuge in a line of argument that was never taught by Aris-
totle and his school. He says, “It was good and proper that He should beget His Son at that
time when He willed: and in the minds of sensible men there does not hence arise any
questioning why He did not do so before.” What does this mean, Eunomius? Are you too
going afoot like us unlettered men? are you leaving your artistic periods and actually taking
refuge in unreasoning assent? you, who so much reproached those who take in hand to
write without logical skill? You, who say to Basil, “You show your own ignorance when you
say that definitions of the terms that express things spiritual are an impossibility for men,”
who again elsewhere advance the same charge, “you make your own impotence common
to others, when you declare that what is not possible for you is impossible for all”? Is this
the way that you, who say such things as these, approach the ears of him who questions
about the reason why the Father defers becoming the Father of such a Son? Do you think
it an adequate explanation to say, “He begat Him at that time when He chose: let there be
no questioning on this point”? Has your apprehensive fancy grown so feeble in the mainten-
ance of your doctrines? What has become of your premises that lead to dilemmas? What
has become of your forcible proofs? how comes it that those terrible and inevitable syllogistic
conclusions of your art have dissolved into vanity and nothingness? “He begat the Son at
that time when He chose: let there be no questioning on this point!” Is this the finished
product of your many labours, of your voluminous undertakings? What was the question
asked? “If it is good and fitting for God to have such a Son, why are we not to believe that
the good is always present with Him909?” What is the answer he makes to us from the very
shrine of his philosophy, tightening the bonds of his argument by inevitable necessity? “He
made the Son at that time when He chose: let there be no questioning as to why He did not
do so before.” Why, if the inquiry before us were concerning some irrational being, that
acts by natural impulse, why it did not sooner do whatever it may be,—why the spider did
not make her webs, or the bee her honey, or the turtle-dove her nest,—what else could you
have said? would not the same answer have been ready—“She did it at that time when she
chose: let there be no questioning on this matter”? Nay, if it were concerning some sculptor
or painter who works in paintings or in sculptures by his imitative art, whatever it may be
909 Cf. S. Basil adv. Eun. II. 12, quoted above, p. 207.
He then ingeniously shows that the generation of the Son is not according to the phrase of Eunomius, “The Father begat Him at that time when He chose, and not before:” but that the Son, being the fulness of all that is good and excellent, is always contemplated in the Father; using for this demonstration the support of Eunomius' own arguments.
408
He then ingeniously shows that the generation of the Son is not according…