Chapter
XXIX.—The Pythagorean Doctrine Refuted by Its Own First
Principle, that Living Men are Formed from the Dead.
It is indeed, manifest that dead men are formed from
living ones; but it does not follow from that, that living men are
formed from dead ones. For from the beginning the living came first in
the order of things, and therefore also from the beginning the dead
came afterwards in order. But these proceeded from no other source
except from the living. The living had their origin in any other source
(you please) than in the dead; whilst the dead had no source whence to
derive their beginning, except from the living.
If, then, from the very first the living
came not from the dead, why should they afterwards (be said to) come
from the dead? Had that original source, whatever it was, come to an
end? Was the form or law thereof a matter for regret? Then why was it
preserved in the case of the dead? Does it not follow that, because the
dead came from the living at the first, therefore they always came from
the living? For either the law which obtained at the beginning must
have continued in both of its relations, or else it must have changed
in both; so that, if it had become necessary for the living afterwards
to proceed from the dead, it would be necessary, in like manner, for
the dead also not to proceed from the living. For if a faithful
adherence to the institution was not meant to be perpetuated in each
respect, then contraries cannot in due alternation continue to be
re-formed from contraries. We, too, will on our side adduce against you
certain contraries, of the born and the unborn, of vision
1710
and blindness, of youth and old age, of
wisdom and folly. Now it does not follow that the unborn proceeds from
the born, on the ground that a contrary issues from a contrary; nor,
again, that vision proceeds from blindness, because blindness happens
to vision; nor, again, that youth revives from old age, because after
youth comes the decrepitude of senility; nor that folly
1711
is born with its obtuseness from wisdom,
because wisdom may possibly be sometimes sharpened out of folly.
Albinus has some fears for his (master and friend) Plato in these
points, and labours with much ingenuity to distinguish different kinds
of contraries; as if these instances did not as absolutely partake of
the nature of contrariety as those which are expounded by him to
illustrate his great master’s principle—I mean, life and
death. Nor is it, for the matter of that, true that life is
restored out of death, because it happens that death succeeds
1712
life.
1710
Visualitatis.
1711
Insipientiam.
“Imbecility” is the meaning here, though the word takes the
more general sense in the next clause.
1712
Deferatur.