come from God on the one side, and with Christ on the other side, seeming, as the Son of
God, to say that he came not to destroy these things, but to fulfill them, what was to prevent
me from becoming a Jew? The wise instruction of Manichæus saved me from this danger.
6. But how can you venture to quote this verse against me? Or why should it be against
me only, when it is as much against yourself? If Christ does not destroy the law and the
prophets, neither must Christians do so. Why then do you destroy them? Do you begin to
perceive that you are no Christian? How can you profane with all kinds of work the day
pronounced sacred in the law and in all the prophets, on which they say that God, the maker
of the world, himself rested, without dreading the penalty of death pronounced against
Sabbath-breakers, or the curse on the transgressor? How can you refuse to receive in your
person the unseemly mark of circumcision, which the law and all the prophets declare to
be honorable, especially in the case of Abraham, after what was thought to be his faith; for
does not the God of the Jews proclaim that whosoever is without this mark of infamy shall
perish from his people? How can you neglect the appointed sacrifices, which were made
so much of both by Moses and the prophets under the law, and by Abraham in his faith?
And how can you defile your souls by making no distinction in foods, if you believe that
Christ came not to destroy these things, but to fulfill them? Why do you discard the annual
feast of unleavened bread, and the appointed sacrifice of the lamb, which, according to the
law and the prophets, is to be observed for ever? Why, in a word, do you treat so lightly the
new moons, the baptisms, and the feast of tabernacles, and all the other carnal ordinances
of the law and the prophets, if Christ did not destroy them? I have therefore good reason
for saying that, in order to justify your neglect of these things, you must either abandon
your profession of being Christ’s disciple, or acknowledge that Christ himself has already
destroyed them; and from this acknowledgment it must follow, either that this text is
spurious in which Christ is made to say that he came not to destroy the law, but to fulfill it,
or that the words have an entirely different meaning from what you suppose.
7. Augustin replied: If you allow, in consideration of the authority of the Gospel, that
Christ said that He came not to destroy the law and the prophets, but to fulfill them, you
should show the same consideration to the authority of the apostle, when he says, "All these
things were our examples;" and again of Christ, "He was not yea and nay, but in Him was
yea; for all the promises of God are in Him yea;"669 that is, they are set forth and fulfilled in
Him. In this way you will see in the clearest light both what law Christ fulfilled, and how
He fulfilled it. It is a vain attempt that you make to escape by your three kinds of law and
your three kinds of prophets. It is quite plain, and the New Testament leaves no doubt on
the matter, what law and what prophets Christ came not to destroy, but to fulfill. The law
given by Moses is that which by Jesus Christ became grace and truth.670 The law given by
669 2 Cor. i. 19, 20.
670 John i. 17.
412
Faustus is willing to admit that Christ may have said that He came not to…