Chapter 13.—Whether, in Computing Years, We Ought to Follow the Hebrew or the
Septuagint.
But if I say this, I shall presently be answered, It is one of the Jews’ lies. This, however,
we have disposed of above, showing that it cannot be that men of so just a reputation as the
seventy translators should have falsified their version. However, if I ask them which of the
two is more credible, that the Jewish nation, scattered far and wide, could have unanimously
conspired to forge this lie, and so, through envying others the authority of their Scriptures,
have deprived themselves of their verity; or that seventy men, who were also themselves
Jews, shut up in one place (for Ptolemy king of Egypt had got them together for this work),
should have envied foreign nations that same truth, and by common consent inserted these
errors: who does not see which can be more naturally and readily believed? But far be it
from any prudent man to believe either that the Jews, however malicious and wrong-headed,
could have tampered with so many and so widely-dispersed manuscripts; or that those
renowned seventy individuals had any common purpose to grudge the truth to the nations.
One must therefore more plausibly maintain, that when first their labors began to be tran-
scribed from the copy in Ptolemy’s library, some such misstatement might find its way into
the first copy made, and from it might be disseminated far and wide; and that this might
294
arise from no fraud, but from a mere copyist’s error. This is a sufficiently plausible account
of the difficulty regarding Methuselah’s life, and of that other case in which there is a differ-
ence in the total of twenty-four years. But in those cases in which there is a methodical re-
semblance in the falsification, so that uniformly the one version allots to the period before
a son and successor is born 100 years more than the other, and to the period subsequent
100 years less, and vice versâ, so that the totals may agree,—and this holds true of the first,
second, third, fourth, fifth, and seventh generations,—in these cases error seems to have, if
we may say so, a certain kind of constancy, and savors not of accident, but of design.
Accordingly, that diversity of numbers which distinguishes the Hebrew from the Greek
and Latin copies of Scripture, and which consists of a uniform addition and deduction of
100 years in each lifetime for several consecutive generations, is to be attributed neither to
the malice of the Jews nor to men so diligent and prudent as the seventy translators, but to
the error of the copyist who was first allowed to transcribe the manuscript from the library
of the above-mentioned king. For even now, in cases where numbers contribute nothing
to the easier comprehension or more satisfactory knowledge of anything, they are both
carelessly transcribed, and still more carelessly emended. For who will trouble himself to
learn how many thousand men the several tribes of Israel contained? He sees no resulting
benefit of such knowledge. Or how many men are there who are aware of the vast advantage
that lies hid in this knowledge? But in this case, in which during so many consecutive gen-
erations 100 years are added in one manuscript where they are not reckoned in the other,
and then, after the birth of the son and successor, the years which were wanting are added,
Whether, in Computing Years, We Ought to Follow the Hebrew or the Septuagint.
666
Whether, in Computing Years, We Ought to Follow the Hebrew or the Septu…