Introductory Note to the Epistle of
Barnabas
[
a.d.
100.]
The
writer of this Epistle is
supposed to have been an Alexandrian Jew of the times of Trajan and
Hadrian. He was a layman; but possibly he bore the name of
“Barnabas,” and so has been confounded with his holy and
apostolic name-sire. It is more probable that the Epistle, being
anonymous, was attributed to St. Barnabas, by those who supposed that
apostle to be the author of the Epistle to the Hebrews, and who
discovered similarities in the plan and purpose of the two works. It is
with great reluctance that I yield to modern scholars, in dismissing the
ingenious and temperate argument of Archbishop Wake
1438
for the apostolic origin of this treatise. The learned Lardner
1439
shares his convictions; and the very interesting and
ingenious views of Jones
1440
never appeared to me
satisfactory, weighed with preponderating arguments, on the other
side.
1441
The Maccabæan spirit of the Jews never burned more
furiously than after the destruction of Jerusalem, and while it was
kindling the conflagration that broke out under Barchochebas, and blazed
so terribly in the insurrection against Hadrian.
1442
It is not credible
that the Jewish Christians at Alexandria and elsewhere were able to
emancipate themselves from their national spirit; and accordingly the old
Judaizing, which St. Paul had anathematized and confuted, would assert
itself again. If such was the occasion of this Epistle, as I venture to
suppose, a higher character must be ascribed to it than could otherwise
be claimed. This accounts, also, for the degree of favour with which it
was accepted by the primitive faithful.
It is interesting as a specimen of their conflicts with
a persistent Judaism which St. Paul had defeated and anathematized, but
which was ever cropping out among believers originally of the
Hebrews.
1443
Their own habits of allegorizing, and their Oriental tastes, must
be borne in mind, if we are readily disgusted with our author’s
fancies and refinements. St. Paul himself pays a practical tribute to
their modes of thought, in his Epistle to the
Galatians iv.
24
. This is the
ad hominem
form of rhetoric, familiar
to all speakers, which laid even the apostle open to the slander of
enemies (
2 Cor. xii. 16
),—that he was
“crafty,” and caught men with guile. It is interesting to
note the more Occidental spirit of Cyprian, as compared with our author,
when he also contends with Judaism. Doubtless we have in the
pseudo-Barnabas something of that
œconomy
which
is
always capable of abuse, and which was destined too soon to overleap the
bounds of its moral limitations.
It is to be observed that this writer sometimes speaks
as a Gentile, a fact which some have found it difficult to account for,
on the supposition that he was a Hebrew, if not a Levite as well. But so,
also, St. Paul sometimes speaks as a Roman, and sometimes as a Jew; and,
owing to the mixed character of the early Church, he writes to the
Romans iv. 1
as if they were all Israelites, and
again to the same Church (
Rom. xi. 13
) as if they
were all Gentiles. So this writer sometimes identifies himself with
Jewish thought as a son of Abraham, and again speaks from the Christian
position as if he were a Gentile, thus identifying himself with the
catholicity of the Church.
But the subject thus opened is vast; and “the
Epistle of Barnabas,” so called, still awaits a critical editor,
who at the same time shall be a competent expositor. Nobody can answer
these requisitions, who is unable, for this purpose, to be a Christian of
the days of Trajan.
But it will be observed that this version has great
advantages over any of its predecessor, and is a valuable acquisition to
the student. The learned translators have had before them the entire
Greek text of the fourth century, disfigured it is true by corruptions, but
still very precious, the rather as they have been able to compare it with
the text of Hilgenfeld. Their editorial notes are sufficient for our own
plan; and little has been left for me to do, according to the scheme of
this publication, save to revise the “copy” for printing. I
am glad to presume no further into such a labyrinth, concerning which the
learned and careful Wake modestly professes, “I have endeavoured to
attain to the sense of my author, and to make him as plain and easy as I
was able. If in anything I have chanced to mistake him, I have only this
to say for myself: that he must be better acquainted with the road than I
pretend to be, who will undertake to travel so long a journey in the dark
and never to miss his way.”
The following is the original
Introductory Notice
:—
Nothing
certain is known as to the author of the following Epistle. The
writer’s name is Barnabas, but scarcely any scholars now ascribe it
to the illustrious friend and companion of St. Paul. External and
internal evidence here come into direct collision. The ancient writers
who refer to this Epistle unanimously attribute it to Barnabas the
Levite, of Cyprus, who held such an honourable place in the infant
Church. Clement of Alexandria does so again and again (
Strom.
, ii.
6, ii. 7, etc.). Origen describes it as “a Catholic Epistle”
(
Cont. Cels.
, i. 63), and seems to rank it among the Sacred
Scriptures (
Comm. in Rom.
, i. 24). Other statements have been
quoted from the fathers, to show that they held this to be an authentic
production of the apostolic Barnabas; and certainly no other name is ever
hinted at in Christian antiquity as that of the writer. But
notwithstanding this, the internal evidence is now generally regarded as
conclusive against this opinion. On perusing the Epistle, the reader will
be in circumstances to judge of this matter for himself. He will be led
to consider whether the spirit and tone of the writing, as so decidedly
opposed to all respect for Judaism—the numerous inaccuracies
which it contains with respect to Mosaic enactments and observances
—the absurd and trifling interpretations of Scripture which it
suggests—and the many silly vaunts of superior knowledge in which
its writer indulges—can possibly comport with its ascription to
the fellow—labourer of St. Paul. When it is remembered that no
one ascribes the Epistle to the apostolic Barnabas till the times of
Clement of Alexandria, and that it is ranked by Eusebius among the
“spurious” writings, which, however much known and read in
the Church, were never regarded as authoritative, little doubt can remain
that the external evidence is of itself weak, and should not make us
hesitate for a moment in refusing to ascribe this writing to Barnabas the
Apostle.
The date, object, and intended reader of the Epistle
can only be doubtfully inferred from some statements which it contains.
It was clearly written after the destruction of Jerusalem,
since reference is made to that event (chap. xvi.), but how long
after is matter of much dispute. The general opinion is, that its date is
not later than the middle of the second century, and that it cannot be
placed earlier than some twenty or thirty years before. In point of
style, both as respects thought and expression, a very low place must be
assigned it. We know nothing certain of the region in which the author
lived, or where the first readers were to be found. The intention of the
writer, as he himself states (chap. i), was “to perfect the
knowledge” of those to whom he wrote. Hilgenfeld, who has devoted
much attention to this Epistle, holds that “it was written at the
close of the first century by a Gentile Christian of the school of
Alexandria, with the view of winning back, or guarding from a Judaic form
of Christianity, those Christians belonging to the same class as
himself.”
Until the recent discovery of the Codex Sinaiticus by
Tischendorf, the first four and a half chapters were known only in an
ancient Latin version. The whole Greek text is now happily recovered,
though it is in many places very corrupt. We have compared its readings
throughout, and noted the principal variations from the text represented
in our version. We have also made frequent reference to the text adopted
by Hilgenfeld in his recent edition of the Epistle (Lipsiæ, T. O.
Weigel, 1886).
1438
Discourse (p. 148) to his
Genuine
Epistles of the Apostolical Fathers
. Philadelphia, 1846.
1439
Works, ii. 250, note; and iv.
128.
1440
On the Canon
, vol. ii. p. 431.
1441
To those who may
adhere to the older opinion, let me commend the eloquent and instructive
chapter (xxiii.) in Farrar’s
Life of St. Paul
.
1442
Hadrian’s purpose to rebuild their
city seems to be pointed out in chap. xvi.
1443
M. Renan may be
read with pain, and yet with profit, in much that his Gallio-spirit
suggests on this subject. Chap. v.,
St. Paul
, Paris, 1884.