I now proceed to quote, I lay them before the reader as the results of the most advanced
criticism in the matter.
(Duchesne. Origines du Culte Chrétien, p. 54 et seq.)
All known liturgies may be reduced to four principal types—the Syrian, the Alexandrian,
the Roman, and the Gallican. In the fourth century there certainly existed these four types
at the least, for the Syrian had already given rise to several sub-types which were clearly
marked.
The most ancient documents of the Syrian Liturgy are:
1. The Catechetical Lectures of St. Cyril of Jerusalem, delivered about the year 347.
2. The Apostolic Constitutions (Bk. II., 57, and Bk. VIII., 5–15).
3. The homilies of St. John Chrysostom.
St. John Chrysostom often quotes lines of thought and even prayers taken from the
liturgy. Bingham190 was the first to have the idea of gathering together and putting in order
these scattered references. This work has been recently taken in hand afresh by Mr. Ham-
mond.191 From this one can find much interesting corroborative evidence, but the orator
does not give anywhere a systematic description of the liturgy, in the order of its rites and
prayers.
The Catechetical Lectures of St. Cyril are really a commentary upon the ceremonies of
the mass, made to the neophytes after their initiation. The preacher does not treat of the
missa catechumenorum because his hearers had so long been familiar with it; he presupposes
the bread and wine to have been brought to and placed upon the altar, and begins at the
moment when the bishop prepares himself to celebrate the Holy Mysteries by washing his
hands.
In the Apostolic Constitutions a distinction must be drawn between Book II. and Book
VIII. The first is very sketchy; it only contains a description of the rites without the words
used, the other gives at length all the formulas of the prayers, but only from the end of the
Gospel.
We know now that the Apostolical Constitutions in the present state of the Greek text
represent a melting down and fusing together of two analogous books—the Didaskale of
the Apostles, of which only a Syriac version is extant; and the Didake of the Apostles, recently
discovered by the metropolitan, Philotheus Bryennius. The first of these two books has
served as a basis for the first six books of the Apostolical Constitutions. The second, much
spread out, has become the seventh book of the same collection. The eighth book is more
homogeneous. It must have been added to the seven others by the author of the recension
of the Didaskaleand of the Didake. This author is the same as he who made the interpolations
190 Bingham, Antiquities, XIII. 6.
191 Hammond. The Ancient Liturgy of Antioch (Oxford, 1879).
270
Excursus on the Worship of the Early Church.