Chapter 40.—46. For if the baptism which Prætextatus and Felicianus administered in
the communion of Maximianus was their own, why was it received by you in those whom
they baptized as though it were the baptism of Christ? But if it is truly the baptism of Christ,
as indeed it is, and yet could not profit those who had received it with the guilt of schism,
what do you say that you could have granted to those whom you have received into your
body with the same baptism, except that, now that the offense of their accursed division is
wiped out by the bond of peace, they should not be compelled to receive the sacrament of
the holy laver as though they had it not, but that, as what they had was before for their de-
struction, so it should now begin to be of profit to them? Or if this is not granted to them
in your communion, because it could not possibly be that it should be granted to schismatics
among schismatics, it is at any rate granted to you in the Catholic communion, not that you
should receive baptism as though it were lacking in you, but that the baptism which you
have actually received should be of profit to you. For all the sacraments of Christ, if not
616
combined with the love which belongs to the unity of Christ, are possessed not unto salvation,
but unto judgment. But since it is not a true verdict, but your verdict, "that through the
baptism of certain traditors the baptism of Christ has perished from the world in general,"
it is with good reason that you cannot find any answer to make respecting the recognition
of the baptism of the followers of Maximianus.
47. See therefore, and remember with the most watchful care, how Petilianus has made
no answer to that very question, which he proposes to himself in such terms as to seem to
make it a starting-point from which to say something. For the former question he has dis-
missed altogether, and has not wished to speak of it to us, because I suppose it was beyond
his power; nor is he at any time, up to the very end of his volume, going to say anything
about it, though he quoted it from the first part of my epistle as though it were a matter
calling for refutation. For even though he has added the two words which he accused me
of having suppressed, as though they were the strongest bulwarks of his position, he yet lies
wholly defenseless, unable to find any answer to make when he is asked, If the conscience
of one that gives in holiness is what we look for to cleanse the conscience of the recipient,
where are we to find means for cleansing the conscience of the man who is unacquainted
with the conscience of him gives, but not in holiness? and if it be the case that any one who
has received his faith from one that is faithless, receives not faith but guilt, from what source
is he to receive not guilt but faith, who is unwittingly baptized by one that is faithless? To
this question it has long been manifest from what he says that he has made no answer.
48. In the next place, he has gone on, with calumnious mouth, to abuse monasteries
and monks, finding fault also with me, as having been the founder of this kind of life.2406
And what this kind of life really is he does not know at all, or rather, though it is perfectly
2406 See Possidius’ Life of St. Augustin, cc. v.-xi.
Chapter 40
1227
Chapter 40