for things of this nature, as a discriminating mark of a true Christian. (Ser. on Christ a King
and Witness, p. 19. c.) Under a use of examination, he there says, “Do you depend on Christ
to protect you from all your spiritual enemies, to restore you to holiness, to subdue all your
heart to the will of God, to make you partakers of his image and moral perfections, and in
that way to preserve and lead you to your true perfection and eternal happiness.”
Mr. W. supposes (p. 36. a. b. c.) that the profession men must make in order to come
to sacraments, implies real friendship to God, loving God more than his enemies, loving
him above the world; and therefore according to Mr. W. unsanctified men may make this
profession also, and speak true: contrary to the whole current of Scripture, which represents
unsanctified men as the enemies of God, those that have not the love of God in them, under
the power of a carnal mind, &c.—And contrary to the unanimous voice of all sound divines,
yea, of the whole christian world. Mr. W. in the forementioned place blames me, that I had
intimated (as he supposes) that the profession which Mr. Stoddard taught to be necessary,
did not imply real friendship, and loving God above his enemies, and above the world. Let
us then compare this with Mr. S—d’s doctrine, as extant in his writings. He speaks of it as
a property of saving grace, wherein it specifically differs from common grace, that a true
love to God prizes God above all the world. (Nat. of Sav. Conv. p. 7. b. c.) That every natural
man prefers vain and base things before God. (Ibid. p. 96. b.) That they are all enemies to
God, and the very being of God. (Ibid. p. 5. c. d. and p. 97.) That their hearts are full of
enmity to God. (Ibid. p. 55. e.) That they have an aversion to those gracious actions of loving
God, and trusting in Christ, and are under the dominion of a contrary inclination. (Ibid. p.
67.) That those of them whose consciences are enlightened, and are reforming their lives,
have no love; and that it is a burden to them that they suspect there is such a God, that they
wish there was not such an one. And that they are haters of God, and are so addicted to
their own interest, that they have a bitter spirit towards God, have an ill affection to him,
and are adversaries to his felicity. (Ibid. p. 97. Three Serm. p. 38, 39.) That they are governed
by a spirit of self-love, and are wholly destitute of love to God; that some of them confess
that they have but little love to God; but indeed they have not one spark of love to God in
their hearts. (Three Serm. p. 48.) That they set their interest at the right hand of God’s
glory,—as if God’s honour were not to be regarded, compared with their interest, &c. &c.
(Ibid. p. 63, 64.)
So Mr. W. himself (Christ a King and Witness, p. 145. e.) plainly supposes, that before
conversion men love the world more than God. For, speaking of the nature of the change
wrought in conversion, he says, things are quite turned about, God and Christ are got into
the place the world had before. Again (Ibid. p. 18. b.) he says, “You must know that there
is no man who is not either a true subject to Christ, or his enemy. That man who does not
submit to Christ as his King and Lord, by bearing true faith and allegiance to him, is the
enemy of Christ and his kingdom. Such are all they who will not depend on him, believe in
1937
SECTION V. Mr. W. inconsistent with Mr. Stoddard.