Chapter 11.—Whether the Angels that Fell Partook of the Blessedness Which the Holy
Angels Have Always Enjoyed from the Time of Their Creation.
And since these things are so, those spirits whom we call angels were never at any time
or in any way darkness, but, as soon as they were made, were made light; yet they were not
so created in order that they might exist and live in any way whatever, but were enlightened
that they might live wisely and blessedly. Some of them, having turned away from this light,
have not won this wise and blessed life, which is certainly eternal, and accompanied with
the sure confidence of its eternity; but they have still the life of reason, though darkened
with folly, and this they cannot lose even if they would. But who can determine to what
extent they were partakers of that wisdom before they fell? And how shall we say that they
participated in it equally with those who through it are truly and fully blessed, resting in a
212
true certainty of eternal felicity? For if they had equally participated in this true knowledge,
then the evil angels would have remained eternally blessed equally with the good, because
they were equally expectant of it. For, though a life be never so long, it cannot be truly called
eternal if it is destined to have an end; for it is called life inasmuch as it is lived, but eternal
because it has no end. Wherefore, although everything eternal is not therefore blessed (for
hell-fire is eternal), yet if no life can be truly and perfectly blessed except it be eternal, the
life of these angels was not blessed, for it was doomed to end, and therefore not eternal,
whether they knew it or not. In the one case fear, in the other ignorance, prevented them
from being blessed. And even if their ignorance was not so great as to breed in them a
wholly false expectation, but left them wavering in uncertainty whether their good would
be eternal or would some time terminate, this very doubt concerning so grand a destiny was
incompatible with the plenitude of blessedness which we believe the holy angels enjoyed.
For we do not so narrow and restrict the application of the term “blessedness” as to apply
it to God only,472 though doubtless He is so truly blessed that greater blessedness cannot
be; and, in comparison of His blessedness, what is that of the angels, though, according to
their capacity, they be perfectly blessed?
472 Vives remarks that the ancients defined blessedness as an absolutely perfect state in all good, peculiar to
God. Perhaps Augustin had a reminiscence of the remarkable discussion in the Tusc. Disp. lib. v., and the
definition, Neque ulla alia huic verbo, quum beatum dicimus, subjecta notio est, nisi, secretis malis omnibus, cu-
mulata bonorum complexio.
Whether the Angels that Fell Partook of the Blessedness Which the Holy Angels Have Always Enjoyed from the Time of Their Creation.
483
Whether the Angels that Fell Partook of the Blessedness Which the Holy Angels…