being steward of both boarding-schools, by which he will have the opportunity of supplying
the Indians out of his own shop, and of getting his pay from the British funds; a design of
introducing his son, as the master of the boarding-school, under the idea of a present supply,
another proper person not appearing; and an expectation of diverting the king’s bounty, of
£500 sterling, to the Six Nations, from New York. The former school-master has given hints
of an agreement, between himself and him, to resign the care of Mr. Hollis’s scholars to
him, when things are ripe for it, he providing for their maintenance, and taking care of their
instruction by his son. Beside these things, his wife is to be mistress of the female school;
and two of their sons to be maintained and educated at the public expense, and two of their
girls, in like manner, to be maintained in the female school; and one of his family to be his
wife’s usher; and his servants to be paid for, under the character of servants employed in
the affairs of the female school; and the house for the boarding-school set on his wife’s land;
and then the farm to be bought by the country for the school, with the advantage of selling
it at a high rate; and yet the family in a great measure to be maintained on the produce of
it; beside the advantage of carrying on a trade, both with the Stockbridge Indians and the
Mohawks. A man had need to have a great stock of assuredness, to urge a public affair, under
so manifold temptations of private interest.”
The time of Mr. Edwards had been so much occupied by his removal from Northampton,
the comfortable establishment of his family at Stockbridge, the ordinary duties of his parish
and his mission, the claims of the Mohawks, the concerns of the various Indian schools,
and the unhappy contentions of the whites; that he had, at first, no leisure to attend to the
Reply of Mr. Williams. In the latter part of the spring, however, he began an answer to that
gentleman, which he sent to the press the beginning of July 50 , with the following title
“Misrepresentations Corrected, and Truth Vindicated, in a Reply to the Rev Mr. Solomon
Williams’s Book, entitled, The True State of the Question, concerning the Qualifications ne-
cessary to Lawful Communion in the Christian Sacraments.“ It was read with deep interest
by both parties, was admitted by both to be a triumphant answer to the “True State of the
Question,” and, taken in connexion with the” Humble Attempt,” was regarded by the friends
of strict communion, at that time, as it has ever since been, as an unanswerable defense of
their system. If the opposers of that system have not so regarded it, they have not publicly
avowed the opposite opinion; as no attempt to answer it has hitherto appeared. Mr. Williams
is said to have asked the advice of some of his friends, among the clergy, whether he had
better commence a reply; but, finding that no one would encourage him to an attempt,
which must end in reiterated defeat, he is reported to have sat down in mortified silence.
Appended to this publication was a letter from Mr. Edwards to his late flock at
Northampton. They had published Mr. Williams’s pamphlet at their own expense, and
50 It was not published until November.
300
CHAPTER XX. Letter to Sir W. Pepperell. Letter to Lady Pepperell. Letter…