to increase in the world, men refused to persevere, and the Christian religion was lost from
all the nations with the exception of the Donatists. All this, replies Augustin, as if the Spirit
of God did not know the future volitions of men. But Christ, after the resurrection, said
that the Law, the Prophets and the Psalms testified of Him, and that the fulfillment of his
kingdom should begin from Jerusalem. He then follows out the expansion of the Church
as given in the Acts, and the foundation of Christian communities as mentioned in the
Epistles and the Revelation. The Donatists reply to this theory of development that the
Church perished save among them in North Africa. It is among the few: for which they
cite a similar state of things under Enoch, Noah, Lot, Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, and the
Kingdom of Judah. The spread of the Church did indeed begin from Jerusalem, but after-
wards an apostasy befell it, in the progress of which the communion of the Donatists alone
remained faithful. Augustin says the fact that there are evil persons in the Church is simply
a proof of the fulfillment of those parables of our Lord, which illustrate the mixed characters
in his kingdom. There is indeed a paucity of the good, but within that communion. Then
follows a discussion of the geographical limitation, the Donatists maintaining that the Ori-
ental churches and the rest mentioned in the sacred canon had receded from the faith. Es-
pecially is their favorite paragraph, a passage from Cant. i. 7, commented upon. He presses
the continuous preaching among all nations, after which event the end is to come; there
must be such a universal growth to that end. Let us cease drawing from the acts and sayings
of men about this great matter, and take the simple testimony of the Scriptures. But the
Donatists object: If the Church be among you why do you compel us by force to enter its
peace? Or if we are evil why do you desire us? and if we are tares why hinder us from
growing until the harvest? Augustin then justifies the system of correction adopted in loving
care for their salvation, not failing to remind them of the Circumcelliones and their own
384
action with regard to the Maximianists. Another inquiry of the Donatists was, How will
you recognize us if we come to you? Augustin says, as the universally founded Church is
wont to receive, put away all hatred and your sacraments are acknowledged. This leads to
the discussion of baptism and of that related topic, the effect, of the celebrant’s character,
upon the recipient. He returns finally to the note of universality as essential to the unity,
with the one Head and the one body.
Somewhere about 404 A.D. two official cases of discipline had occurred in Augustin’s
monasterium, which had grieved the pride of the clergy, because they had boasted of their
establishment as really purer than the puristic body gathered about the Donatist bishop
Proculeianus. They were more troubled about this than about the sins of the suspected
brethren, one of whom, however, seemed to have considerable injustice done him. While
discussing this matter [in Ep. lxxviii.] he incidentally mentions the lapse of two Donatists,
who had been received into Augustin’s communion, and whose conduct the clergy had re-
garded as a proof of the laxity of discipline under Proculeianus.
662
An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.