CHAP. XL] MEMORY IS ALSO OF THINGS PRESENT. 361
knowable things generate knowledge, and are not generated by-
knowledge. But when knowledge has come to pass, when-
ever the things known and laid up in memory are reviewed
by recollection, who does not see that the retaining them in
the memory is prior in time to the sight of them in recollec-
tion, and to the uniting of the two things by will as a third ?
In the mind, however, it is not so. For the mind is not ad-
ventitious to itself, as though there came to itself already
existing, that same self not already existing, from somewhere
else ; or did not indeed come from somewhere else, but that
in the mind itself already existing, there was born that same
mind not already existing; just as faith, which before was
not, arises in the mind which already was. Nor does the mind
see itself, as it were, set up in its own memory by recollection
subsequently to the knowing of itself, as though it was not
there before it knew itself; whereas, doubtless, from the time
when it began to be, it has never ceased to remember, to under-
stand, and to love itself, as we have already shown. And
hence, when it is turned to itself by thought, there arises a
trinity, in which now at length we can discern also a word
;
since it is formed from thought itself, will uniting both. Here,
then, we may recognise, more than we have hitherto done, the
image of which we are in search.
Chap. xi.—Whether memory is also ofthingspresent.
14. But some one will say. That is not memory by which
the mind, which is ever present to itself, is affirmed to remem-
ber itself ; for memory is of things past, not of things present.
For there are some, and among them Cicero, who, in treating
of the virtues, have divided prudence into these three
—
memory, understanding, forethought : to wit, assigning memory
to things past, understanding to things present, forethought to
things future ; which last is certain only in the case of thosewho
are prescient of the future ; and this is no gift of men, unless
it be granted from above, as to the prophets. And hence the
book of Wisdom, speaking of men, " The thoughts of mortals,"
it says, "are fearful, and our forethought uncertain."-^ But
memory of things past, and understanding of things present, are
^Wisd. ix. 14.