This was the question which came into discussion in the Nestorian controversy, when, as it was then expressed, all that took place in respect to the Eternal Word as man, belonged to His Person, and therefore might be predicated of Him; so that it was heretical not to confess the Word’s body (or the body of God in the Person of the Word), the Word’s death (as Athan, in the text), the Word’s exaltation, and the Word’s, or God’s, Mother, who was in consequence called θεοτόκος, which was the expression on which the controversy mainly turned. Cf. Orat. iii. 31, a passage as precise as if it had been written after the Nestorian and Eutychian controversies, though without the technical words then adopted.
{"author":"Historical editor/translator (individual note author unspecified)","date_end":1892,"date_label":"1892 (historical English edition; transcription printing date uncertain)","date_start":1892,"edition_year":1892,"edition_year_basis":"Original NPNF Series II Volume IV title and copyright1892; exact physical printing underlying Wikisource transcription not established","id":"ws-library-full-note:a29520df15bd4792dd31:cite_note-55","is_genuine_commentary_verified":false,"license_url":"https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Wikisource:Reusing_Wikisource_content","public_import_allowed":true,"publication_location":"source-library","record_type":"editorial-footnote","references":[],"rights_approved":true,"section":"Discourse 1, Chapter 11, Section 45, editorial note cite_note-55","semantic_kind_reviewed":false,"source_context":[{"$text_sha256":"bb68b12a7e574055e75fbb2c1250d1269bb53bb5cef9e4a0fc743f215b20c8d0"}],"source_library_url":"/library/a29520df15bd4792dd31/#ws-library-full-note:a29520df15bd4792dd31:cite_note-55","source_url":"https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Nicene_and_Post-Nicene_Fathers:_Series_II/Volume_IV/Against_the_Arians/Against_the_Arians/Discourse_I/Chapter_11#cite_note-55","translator":"John Henry Newman (translation and notes); Archibald Robertson (revision)","verification":{"note":{"backlink_hrefs":["#cite_ref-55"],"body_html":{"$text_sha256":"7e92c03bc5ba3fac57f9d5338ef203771c90a9955c092eff5402f167587836c8"},"body_xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[2]/ol/li[55]/span[2]","container_html":{"$text_sha256":"04be2564b754622306c92fe6b3066a375dfee88535f4afc2745f7c36c5500268"},"container_xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[2]/ol/li[55]","id":"cite_note-55"},"original_work_coordinate":{"actual_note_parent_coordinates":[{"chapter":11,"native_section_number":45,"original_parent_paragraph":{"dom_serialized_html":{"$text_sha256":"407d61eb50b9362a4a78b2e052a984bbadbe0e880e4043db0a8c1366e1523b64"},"dom_serialized_sha256":"407d61eb50b9362a4a78b2e052a984bbadbe0e880e4043db0a8c1366e1523b64","original_node_id":"mwAX0","source_id":"a29520df15bd4792dd31","source_path":"raw/research/wikisource/patristic-series-stage6/a29520df15bd4792dd31.html","source_sha256":"9710dd6c51d6f121e49f03b1858b0d86dea9a873b27e2d9262118a0dda26d7e9","text":{"$text_sha256":"bb68b12a7e574055e75fbb2c1250d1269bb53bb5cef9e4a0fc743f215b20c8d0"},"xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[1]/p[10]"},"source_paragraph_index":10}],"actual_original_chapter_number":11,"actual_original_discourse_number":1,"actual_original_letter_number":null,"chapter":11,"discourse":1,"letter":null,"native_section_number":45,"numbering_basis":"Literal original p headings and actual observed reading-body catalogue ancestry; URL ordinals never treated as native chapter/letter numbers","original_chapter_heading":{"$text_sha256":"bf14c3c89c7595c044768501d733fcaf787f2509e771dfd3f8f076eeefda4c8f"},"original_heading_evidence":[{"discourse":1,"heading_source_id":"347c934f7cfb86dd3883","heading_source_node":{"html":{"$text_sha256":"c90edb27f00ca9b2bf47a48b8fa058c1d0e8a3caa71fc7b60e43d897b86eac29"},"html_sha256":"c90edb27f00ca9b2bf47a48b8fa058c1d0e8a3caa71fc7b60e43d897b86eac29","source_html":{"$text_sha256":"c90edb27f00ca9b2bf47a48b8fa058c1d0e8a3caa71fc7b60e43d897b86eac29"},"source_html_sha256":"c90edb27f00ca9b2bf47a48b8fa058c1d0e8a3caa71fc7b60e43d897b86eac29","source_utf8_byte_end":49156,"source_utf8_byte_start":49127,"xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[1]/p[2]"},"heading_source_record_id":"ancl:347c934f7cfb86dd3883:p:2","original_discourse_heading":"Discourse I."},{"chapter":11,"heading_source_node":{"html":{"$text_sha256":"a254b07634ca93b4ab10b71bf1aa3e0e06c6aab4e696cc92ff502e6d4e3eb38e"},"html_sha256":"a254b07634ca93b4ab10b71bf1aa3e0e06c6aab4e696cc92ff502e6d4e3eb38e","source_html":{"$text_sha256":"6c57810beeda2d75fb9ec8fb0c5f5f7f492221fcf2d10e175d21d65a7af800c6"},"source_html_sha256":"6c57810beeda2d75fb9ec8fb0c5f5f7f492221fcf2d10e175d21d65a7af800c6","source_utf8_byte_end":51119,"source_utf8_byte_start":49147,"xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[1]/p[1]"},"heading_source_record_id":"ancl:a29520df15bd4792dd31:p:1","original_chapter_heading":{"$text_sha256":"bf14c3c89c7595c044768501d733fcaf787f2509e771dfd3f8f076eeefda4c8f"}}],"original_letter_heading":null,"original_reading_body_catalogue_memberships":[{"actual_anchor_html":{"$text_sha256":"e062754744ee60e912a6b2a28d02fb07a45e6f4d761266caa8b9d371a01cc6c8"},"actual_anchor_xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[2]/ul/li[11]/a","actual_label":"Chapter 11","modern_navigation_excluded":true,"parent_source_id":"5c52ddb7ca5b4896abbf","parent_source_path":"raw/research/wikisource/patristic-series-stage5/5c52ddb7ca5b4896abbf.html","parent_source_sha256":"50bd01a585621098d58ccc2ebca3ba3456b47025829f2812c64a87a4c8850f65"},{"actual_anchor_html":{"$text_sha256":"e062754744ee60e912a6b2a28d02fb07a45e6f4d761266caa8b9d371a01cc6c8"},"actual_anchor_xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[2]/ul/li[11]/a","actual_label":"Chapter 11","actual_original_UL_reading_body_catalogue":true,"modern_navigation_excluded":true,"parent_source_id":"5c52ddb7ca5b4896abbf","parent_source_path":"raw/research/wikisource/patristic-series-stage5/5c52ddb7ca5b4896abbf.html","parent_source_sha256":"50bd01a585621098d58ccc2ebca3ba3456b47025829f2812c64a87a4c8850f65"}],"original_section_range_heading":null,"owner_verified_section_label":"Discourse 1, Chapter 11, Section 45","private_original_node_id":"mw-reference-text-cite_note-55","source_paragraph_index":null,"unestablished_native_number_not_invented":false},"reference_proofs":[],"source_id":"a29520df15bd4792dd31","source_library_context_witnesses":[{"html":{"$text_sha256":"407d61eb50b9362a4a78b2e052a984bbadbe0e880e4043db0a8c1366e1523b64"},"html_sha256":"407d61eb50b9362a4a78b2e052a984bbadbe0e880e4043db0a8c1366e1523b64","xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[1]/p[10]"}],"source_node":{"html":{"$text_sha256":"7e92c03bc5ba3fac57f9d5338ef203771c90a9955c092eff5402f167587836c8"},"html_sha256":"7e92c03bc5ba3fac57f9d5338ef203771c90a9955c092eff5402f167587836c8","xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[2]/ol/li[55]/span[2]"},"source_path":"raw/research/wikisource/patristic-series-stage6/a29520df15bd4792dd31.html","source_record_file":"raw/review/athanasius-psalms-library-note-batch-0090/original-source-records.jsonl","source_record_file_sha256":"4b06e30487b04ff6f328981a08c3956d99fc7f5284b0ab0c262ac0d82cfe56e0","source_record_id":"ws-library-full-note:a29520df15bd4792dd31:cite_note-55","source_sha256":"9710dd6c51d6f121e49f03b1858b0d86dea9a873b27e2d9262118a0dda26d7e9","text_sha256":"8cacbf4e226c5c0af672d10148515e7a86c16aa14ad6564b2135bf44da586053","type":"whole-source-library-dom"},"verified":true,"work":"Discourses Against the Arians (I–III)","work_id":"ws-npnf2-4-athanasius-arians-i-iii"}
{"author":"Historical editor/translator (individual note author unspecified)","date_end":1892,"date_label":"1892 (historical English edition; transcription printing date uncertain)","date_start":1892,"edition_year":1892,"edition_year_basis":"Original NPNF Series II Volume IV title and copyright1892; exact physical printing underlying Wikisource transcription not established","id":"ws-library-full-note:a29520df15bd4792dd31:cite_note-55","is_genuine_commentary_verified":false,"license_url":"https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Wikisource:Reusing_Wikisource_content","public_import_allowed":true,"publication_location":"source-library","record_type":"editorial-footnote","references":[],"rights_approved":true,"section":"Discourse 1, Chapter 11, Section 45, editorial note cite_note-55","semantic_kind_reviewed":false,"source_context":["45. But since He Himself is said to be ‘exalted,’ and God ‘gave’ Him, and the heretics think this a defect or affection in the essence of the Word, it becomes necessary to explain how these words are used. He is said to be exalted from the lower parts of the earth, because death is ascribed even to Him. Both events are reckoned His, since it was His Body, and none other’s, that was exalted from the dead and taken up into heaven. And again, the Body being His, and the Word not being external to it, it is natural that when the Body was exalted, He, as man, should, because of the body, be spoken of as exalted. If then He did not become man, let this not be said of Him: but if the Word became flesh, of necessity the resurrection and exaltation, as in the case of a man, must be ascribed to Him, that the death which is ascribed to Him may be a redemption of the sin of men and an abolition of death, and that the resurrection and exaltation may for His sake remain secure for us. In both respects he hath said of Him, ‘God hath highly exalted Him,’ and ‘God hath given to Him;’ that herein moreover he may show that it is not the Father that hath become flesh, but it is His Word, who has become man, and receives after the manner of men from the Father, and is exalted by Him, as has been said. And it is plain, nor would any one dispute it, that what the Father gives, He gives through. the Son. And it is marvellous and overwhelming verily; for the grace which the Son gives from the Father, that the Son Himself is said to receive; and the exaltation, which the Son bestows from the Father, with that the Son is Himself exalted. For He who is the Son of God, became Himself the Son of Man; and, as Word, He gives from the Father, for all things which the Father does and gives, He does and supplies through Him; and as the Son of Man, He Himself is said after the manner of men to receive what proceeds from Him, because His Body is none other than His, and is a natural recipient of grace, as has been said. For He received it as far as His man’s nature was exalted; which exaltation was its being deified. But such an exaltation the Word Himself always had according to the Father’s Godhead and perfection, which was His."],"source_library_url":"/library/a29520df15bd4792dd31/#ws-library-full-note:a29520df15bd4792dd31:cite_note-55","source_url":"https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Nicene_and_Post-Nicene_Fathers:_Series_II/Volume_IV/Against_the_Arians/Against_the_Arians/Discourse_I/Chapter_11#cite_note-55","translator":"John Henry Newman (translation and notes); Archibald Robertson (revision)","verification":{"proof_file":"raw/review/athanasius-psalms-library-note-batch-0090/proof-records.jsonl","proof_file_sha256":"134f60e56c87c2ec4333e23b6a2d2bf46ade76d1e36ebaa8435bdf01633d4a58","proof_record_id":"ws-library-full-note:a29520df15bd4792dd31:cite_note-55"},"verified":true,"work":"Discourses Against the Arians (I–III)","work_id":"ws-npnf2-4-athanasius-arians-i-iii"}