[I. 24.] Finally the bishops gave way: for on one occasion being summoned as usual into the patriarch's presence, they found not only John there sitting as president, but also some high officers sent to represent the king's person, who sharply reproached them in his name for their obstinacy, saying, 'How long will ye thus resist and prevent the unity of the church of God, which our lord the king, and we also, are anxious to bring about, but which blessing you day by day prevent, and drive away? When will you cease thus to show plainly to all men that you are the disturbers of the church, and you alone? Now therefore, in short, either unite yourselves to us, or make it evident that it is you who trouble and disturb and hinder the unity of the church.' But the bishops in grief and deep sorrow said, 'Were matters justly tried, and by upright rules, it is not we who hinder union, but you, who, while the very centre of your heart is full of the corruption of opposition and division introduced at Chalcedon, wish to make it appear that we are the hinderers, while ye neither have proposed to yourselves, nor shown that you possess even the shadow of unity. What you fraudulently require is, that we should unite ourselves to all the falseness of Chalcedon, without seeking in the least to bring about in a just and upright manner a real union of the church. And now, as we have said from the beginning, if you wish really for unity, and your purpose is not rather to bring about a fraudulent deception and wicked artifice, put away first of all the cause of this division from between us, and at once unity is established in its place. Do not then falsely throw the blame upon us. And besides, supposing that this simple plan has never entered your minds, why, we ask, do you every day thus oppress and wrong us? why do you add to our anxieties pain and the misery of imprisonment, and the other wrongs which without fear of God you inflict upon us, while every day you further torture us with your words, and pierce thorns into our sores? Have you no fear of God, when you see that, lo! already our lives are consumed and spent and gone from the troubles which surround us on all sides? If therefore you really propose to make union, as your words declare, put away the council of Chalcedon, which has troubled and divided, and caused schism in the church, as you yourselves cannot deny, and so will a unity, free from all division, be established throughout the whole church of God.' And to this John and his assessors replied, 'It is you who prevent the ejection of the synod from the church: for if you united yourselves unto us, forthwith the synod also would be ejected, and the unity become complete.' To this the bishops answer, that they can conceive no other explanation of his conduct than the wish to make them accept the council of Chalcedon, 'of which be thou well assured, said they,and all besides, that until the last breath cease from the nostrils of each one of us, the anathema of the synod and of Leo's letter, which conspire in dividing our Lord and God and Saviour into two natures after the union , shall never cease from our mouths.' But John and those with him answered, 'As we have often said before, so now, both we and our lords, their majesties, give you our word, and our oath as in the presence of God, that upon your union with us the synod shall immediately be put away: and whatever comes out of our mouths shall not be changed.' But still the bishops doubted, and said, 'If you really intend to do as you say, why do you not reject the synod at once, that not we alone, but all men without hindrance may join you? Plainly your object is rather to take us by subtlety, and make us accept the heresy of the two natures, and then afterwards you will turn round and laugh at us. If this however be really your purpose, be assured that you delude and deceive your own selves: for we know full well that your purposes and thoughts are not for unity, inasmuch as it is quite evident that what you say is not the truth, and that you pretend to be ready in words only, that we may be thought by every body to be the sole obstacles to union, and be anathematized both by you and all the world as the disturbers of the peace. Nevertheless, we will sacrifice ourselves for the sake of unity, for confiding in your words and promises, and acting as though already the synod were anathematized and ejected, we, with its anathema nevertheless incessantly in our mouths, will communicate with you, once, or if so be, twice; but as for a third time, until the anathematizing and ejection of the synod has taken place, we will have neither part nor communion with you for ever and ever. For we know that you will not establish the truth of your words. But to make it plain and evident to all men that you are not prepared to make unity, but purpose to deceive us and all men, lo! we yield ourselves up to communion with you, as often as two times.' And much more was similarly said and protested on both sides, and so at length the bishops gave way, saying, 'Because of the slanders brought against us by the synodites, see, we yield ourselves up that it may be known that we are not those who prevent union.' For every body blamed them on both sides, saying, 'See, their majesties, and the patriarch are anxious, and in earnest and ready to make union, but those in prison prevent and hinder it.' And therefore they yielded themselves up with great sorrow, and anathematizing with loud voice the council of Chalcedon, submitted themselves to communion twice, as they had promised and agreed, after having strenuously demanded of the king and patriarch, with many adjurations during all those three and thirty days its anathematization and expulsion from the church.
{"author":"Historical John of Ephesus collection (ancient narrative with English translator explanatory bridges)","date_end":null,"date_label":"Date uncertain","date_start":null,"edition_year":null,"edition_year_basis":"Historical Oxford English translation1860; native2002transcription; exact physical printing unestablished","id":"native-john-ephesus:daca0e07a49d11399f83:a9b72034586862f7ee5b","is_genuine_commentary_verified":false,"license_url":"https://tertullian.org/fathers/ephesus_1_book1.htm","public_import_allowed":true,"publication_location":"source-library","record_type":"source-library-passage","references":[],"rights_approved":true,"section":"Original source paragraph 34","semantic_kind_reviewed":false,"source_library_url":"/library/daca0e07a49d11399f83/#native-john-ephesus:daca0e07a49d11399f83:a9b72034586862f7ee5b","source_url":"https://tertullian.org/fathers/ephesus_1_book1.htm#p37","translator":"R. Payne Smith (historical English translation and explanatory bridges,1860); Roger Pearse (2002 transcription, explicitly dedicated to public domain)","verification":{"proof_file":"raw/review/john-ephesus-batch-0152/proof-records.jsonl","proof_file_sha256":"0178d888dc858ca9d0b79f375bdd6a9380f3a30538c33bd103907ef5f5e10664","proof_record_id":"native-john-ephesus:daca0e07a49d11399f83:a9b72034586862f7ee5b"},"verified":true,"work":"Ecclesiastical History of John of Ephesus, Part III, Book 1 (historical Payne Smith English edition, including explanatory bridges)","work_id":"john-ephesus-history-part3-book1"}
{"author":"Historical John of Ephesus collection (ancient narrative with English translator explanatory bridges)","date_end":null,"date_label":"Date uncertain","date_start":null,"edition_year":null,"edition_year_basis":"Historical Oxford English translation1860; native2002transcription; exact physical printing unestablished","id":"native-john-ephesus:daca0e07a49d11399f83:a9b72034586862f7ee5b","is_genuine_commentary_verified":false,"license_url":"https://tertullian.org/fathers/ephesus_1_book1.htm","public_import_allowed":true,"publication_location":"source-library","record_type":"source-library-passage","references":[],"rights_approved":true,"section":"Original source paragraph 34","semantic_kind_reviewed":false,"source_library_url":"/library/daca0e07a49d11399f83/#native-john-ephesus:daca0e07a49d11399f83:a9b72034586862f7ee5b","source_url":"https://tertullian.org/fathers/ephesus_1_book1.htm#p37","translator":"R. Payne Smith (historical English translation and explanatory bridges,1860); Roger Pearse (2002 transcription, explicitly dedicated to public domain)","verification":{"note":null,"reference_proofs":[],"source_id":"daca0e07a49d11399f83","source_node":{"html":{"$text_sha256":"51216e87e12fb33cd924737e8257b2f3f59318f664211f7bc70f7fd65e647f50"},"html_sha256":"51216e87e12fb33cd924737e8257b2f3f59318f664211f7bc70f7fd65e647f50","xpath":"/html/body/p[34]"},"source_paragraph_index":34,"source_path":"raw/review/john-ephesus-payne-smith-source-stage-20261015/daca0e07a49d11399f83.html","source_record_file":"raw/review/john-ephesus-batch-0152/original-source-records.jsonl","source_record_file_bytes":2688788,"source_record_file_sha256":"c343d00b21214d320ca2ab78baf2792439073e891685c3584f0418d9b322577f","source_record_id":"native-john-ephesus:daca0e07a49d11399f83:a9b72034586862f7ee5b","source_sha256":"132e163d61291163ec166323a605cebca57c112b5e8ea2fd0b732636a45f529d","text_sha256":"90e8a5b36efafbd75f3c2ca91d63cf1a1a3748f77de680bbe4d93d08217e6522","type":"whole-john-ephesus-native-prose"},"verified":true,"work":"Ecclesiastical History of John of Ephesus, Part III, Book 1 (historical Payne Smith English edition, including explanatory bridges)","work_id":"john-ephesus-history-part3-book1"}