240
Book XII.
§1. This twelfth book gives a notable interpretation of the words of the Lord to Mary,
“Touch Me not, for I am not yet ascended to My Father.”
But let us see what is the next addition that follows upon this profanity, an addition
which is in fact the key of their defence of their doctrine. For those who would degrade the
majesty of the glory of the Only-begotten to slavish and grovelling conceptions think that
they find the strongest proof of their assertions in the words of the Lord to Mary, which He
uttered after His resurrection, and before His ascension into heaven, saying, “Touch Me
not, for I am not yet ascended to My Father: but go to My brethren and say unto them, I
ascend unto My Father and your Father, and to My God and your God1019.” The orthodox
interpretation of these words, the sense in which we have been accustomed to believe that
they were spoken to Mary, is I think manifest to all who have received the faith in truth.
Still the discussion of this point shall be given by us in its proper place; but meantime it is
worth while to inquire from those who allege against us such phrases as “ascending,” “being
seen,” “being recognized by touch,” and moreover “being associated with men by brother-
hood,” whether they consider them to be proper to the Divine or to the Human Nature. For
if they see in the Godhead the capacity of being seen and touched, of being supported by
meat and drink, kinship and brotherhood with men, and all the attributes of corporeal
nature, then let them predicate of the Only-begotten God both these and whatsoever else
they will, as motive energy and local change, which are peculiar to things circumscribed by
a body. But if He by Mary is discoursing with His brethren, and if the Only-begotten has
no brethren, (for how, if He had brethren, could the property of being Only-begotten be
preserved?) and if the same Person Who said, “God is a Spirit1020,” says to His disciples,
“Handle Me1021,” that He may show that while the Human Nature is capable of being
handled the Divinity is intangible, and if He Who says, “I go,” indicates local change, while
He who contains all things, “in Whom,” as the Apostle says, “all things were created, and
in Whom all things consist1022,” has nothing in existent things external to Himself to which
removal could take place by any kind of motion, (for motion cannot otherwise be effected
than by that which is removed leaving the place in which it is, and occupying another place
instead, while that which extends through all, and is in all, and controls all, and is confined
by no existent thing, has no place to which to pass, inasmuch as nothing is void of the Divine
fulness,) how can these men abandon the belief that such expressions arise from that which
is apparent, and apply them to that Nature which is Divine and which surpasseth all under-
1019 S. John xx. 17
1020 S. John iv. 24
1021 S. Luke xxiv. 39.
1022 Col. i. 16, 17.
Book XIIThis twelfth book gives a notable interpretation of the words of the Lord to Mary, “Touch Me not, for I am not yet ascended to My Father.”
458
Book XII