two, before Christmas,1869 that I received the letter in which you informed me of his intention
to visit the Church at Badesile, by which you fear lest the people be disturbed and influenced
against you. I do not therefore presume to address by letter your people; for I could write a
reply to any who had written to me, but how could I put myself forward unasked to write
to a people not committed to my care?
3. Nevertheless, what I now say to you, who alone have written to me, may, through
you, reach others who should hear it. I charge you then, in the first place, not to bring the
Church into reproach by reading in the public assemblies those writings which the Canon
of the Church has not acknowledged; for by these, heretics, and especially the Manichæans
(of whom I hear that some are lurking, not without encouragement, in your district), are
accustomed to subvert the minds of the inexperienced. I am amazed that a man of your
wisdom should admonish me to forbid the reception into the monastery of those who have
come from you to us, in order that a decree of the Council may be obeyed, and at the same
time should forget another decree1870 of the same Council, declaring what are the canonical
Scriptures which ought to be read to the people. Read again the proceedings of the Council,
and commit them to memory: you will there find that the Canon which you refer to1871 as
prohibiting the indiscriminate reception of applicants for admission to a monastery, was
not framed in regard to laymen, but applies to the clergy alone. It is true there is no mention
of monasteries in the canon; but it is laid down in general, that no one may receive a clergy-
man belonging to another diocese [except in such a way as upholds the discipline of the
Church]. Moreover, it has been enacted in a recent Council,1872 that any who desert a
322
monastery, or are expelled from one, shall not be elsewhere admitted either to clerical office
or to the charge of a monastery. If, therefore, you are in any measure disturbed regarding
Privatio, let me inform you that he has not yet been received by us into the monastery; but
that I have submitted his case to the aged Aurelius, and will act according to his decision.
For it seems strange to me, if a man can be reckoned a Reader who has read only once in
public, and on that occasion read writings which are not canonical. If for this reason he is
regarded as an ecclesiastical reader, it follows that the writing which he read must be esteemed
as sanctioned by the Church. But if the writing be not sanctioned by the Church as canon-
ical, it follows that, although a man may have read it to a congregation, he is not thereby
made an ecclesiastical reader, [but is, as before, a layman]. Nevertheless I must, in regard
to the young man in question, abide by the decision of the arbiter whom I have named.
1869 Pridie Natalis Domini.
1870 See Council of Hippo, A.D. 393, Can. 38, and the third Council of Carthage, A.D. 397, Can. 47.
1871 Ibid. Can. 21.
1872 Council of Carthage, 13th Sept. 401.
725
To Quintianus