universal unfailing tendency to that moral evil, which, according to the real nature and true
demerit of things, as they are in themselves, implies his utter ruin, that must be looked upon
as an evil tendency or propensity; however divine grace may interpose, to save him from
deserved ruin, and to overrule things to an issue contrary to that which they tend to of
themselves. Grace is sovereign, exercised according to the good pleasure of God, bringing
good out of evil. The effect of it belongs not to the nature of things themselves, that otherwise
have an ill tendency, any more than the remedy belongs to the disease; but is something al-
together independent on it, introduced to oppose the natural tendency, and reverse the
course of things. But the event to which things tend, according to their own demerit, and
according to divine justice, is the event to which they tend in their own nature; as Dr. T.’s
own words fully imply, (Pref. to Par. on Rom. p. 131.) “God alone (says he) can declare
whether he will pardon or punish the ungodliness and unrighteousness of mankind, which
is in its own nature punishable.” Nothing is more precisely according to the truth of things,
than divine justice: it weighs things in an even balance; it views and estimates things no
otherwise than they are truly in their own nature. Therefore undoubtedly that which implies
a tendency to ruin, according to the estimate of divine justice, does indeed imply such a
tendency in its own nature.
And then it must be remembered, that it is a moral depravity we are speaking of; and
therefore when we are considering whether such depravity do not appear by a tendency to
a bad effect or issue, it is a moral tendency to such an issue, that is the thing to be taken into
the account. A moral tendency or influence is by desert. Then may it be said, man’s nature
or state is attended with a pernicious or destructive tendency, in a moral sense, when it tends
to that which deserves misery and destruction. And therefore it equally shows the moral
depravity of the nature of mankind in their present state, whether that nature be universally
attended with an effectual tendency to destructive vengeance actually executed, or to their
deserving misery and ruin, or their just exposedness, to destruction, however that fatal con-
sequence may be prevented by grace or whatever the actual event be.
One thing more is to be observed here, that the topic mainly insisted on by the opposers
of the doctrine of original sin, is the justice of God; both in their objections against the im-
putation of Adam’s sin, and also against its being so ordered, that men should come into
the world with a corrupt and ruined nature, without having merited the displeasure of their
Creator by any personal fault. But the latter is not repugnant to God’s justice, if men actually
are born into the world with a tendency to sin, and to misery and ruin for their sin, which
actually will be the consequence, unless mere grace steps in and prevents it. If this be allowed,
the argument from justice is given up: For it is to suppose, that their liableness to misery
and ruin comes in a way of justice; otherwise there would be no need of the interposition
of divine grace to save them. Justice alone would be sufficient security, if exercised, without
grace. It is all one in this dispute about what is just and righteous, whether men are born in
936
SECTION I. All men tend to sin and ruin.