Chapter XXXI.
A kindness received should be returned with a freer hand. This is shown by the example
of the earth. A passage from Solomon about feasting is adduced to prove the same, and is
expounded later in a spiritual sense.
160. It is also right209 that more regard should be paid to him who has conferred some
benefit or gift upon thee, if he ever is reduced to want. For what is so contrary to one’s duty
as not to return what one has received? Nor do I think that a return of equal value should
be made, but a greater. One ought to make up for the enjoyment of a kindness one has re-
ceived from another, to such an extent as to help that person, even to putting an end to his
needs. For not to be the better in returning than in conferring a kindness, is to be the inferior;
for he who was the first to give was the first in point of time, and also first in showing a kind
disposition.
161. Wherefore we must imitate the nature of the earth210 in this respect, which is wont
to return the seed she has received, multiplied a thousand-fold. And so it is written: “As a
field is the foolish man, and as a vineyard is the man without sense. If thou leavest him, he
will be made desolate.”211 As a field also is the wise man, so as to return the seed given him
in fuller measure, as though it had been lent to him on interest. The earth either produces
fruits of its own accord, or pays back and restores, what it was entrusted with, in fruitful
abundance. In both these ways a return is due from thee, when thou enterest upon the use
of thy father’s possession, that thou mayest not be left to lie as an unfruitful field. It may be
that a man can make an excuse for not giving anything, but how can he excuse himself for
not returning what was given? It is hardly right not to give anything; it is certainly not right
to make no return for kindness done to oneself.212
162. Therefore Solomon says well: “When thou sittest to eat at the table of a ruler consider
diligently what is before thee, and put forth thine hand, knowing that it behoves thee to
make such preparations. But if thou art insatiable, be not desirous of his dainties, for they
have but a deceptive life.”213 I have written these words as I wish that we all should follow
them. It is a good thing to do a service, but he who knows not how to return one is very
hard. The earth herself supplies an example of kindliness. She provides fruits of her own
accord, which thou didst not sow; she also returns many-fold what she has received. It is
not right for thee to deny knowledge of money paid in to thee, and how can it be right to
209 Cic. de Off. I. 15, § 47.
210 Cic. de Off. I. 15, § 48.
211 Prov. xxiv. 30 [LXX].
212 Cic. de Off. I. 15, § 48.
213 Prov. xxiii. 1 [LXX.].
Chapter XXXI. A kindness received should be returned with a freer hand. This is shown by the example of the earth. A passage from Solomon about feasting is adduced to prove the same, and is expounded later in a spiritual sense.
87
Chapter XXXI. A kindness received should be returned with a freer hand.…