through a narrow passage, instead of being, as was the case, thrown headlong through the
air, and so caught by the sea monster as to be received into its belly before he was wounded
by its teeth. At the same time, the Scripture does not say whether he had his clothes on or
not when he was cast down into that cavern, so that it may without contradiction be under-
stood that he made that swift descent unclothed, if perchance it was necessary that his gar-
ment should be taken from him, as the shell is taken from an egg, to make him more easily
swallowed. For men are as much concerned about the raiment of this prophet as would be
reasonable if it were stated that he had crept through a very small window, or had been going
into a bath; and yet, even though it were necessary in such circumstances to enter without
parting with one’s clothes, this would be only inconvenient, not miraculous.
32. But perhaps our objectors find it impossible to believe in regard to this divine miracle
that the heated moist air of the belly, whereby food is dissolved, could be so moderated in
temperature as to preserve the life of a man. If so, with how much greater force might they
pronounce it incredible that the three young men cast into the furnace by the impious king
walked unharmed in the midst of the flames! If, therefore, these objectors refuse to believe
any narrative of a divine miracle, they must be refuted by another line of argument. For it
is incumbent on them in that case not to single out some one to be objected to, and called
in question as incredible, but to denounce as incredible all narratives in which miracles of
the same kind or more remarkable are recorded. And yet, if this which is written concerning
Jonah were said to have been done by Apuleius of Madaura or Apollonius of Tyana, by
whom they boast, though unsupported by reliable testimony, that many wonders were
performed (albeit even the devils do some works like those done by the holy angels, not in
truth, but in appearance, not by wisdom, but manifestly by subtlety),—if, I say, any such
event were narrated in connection with these men to whom they give the flattering name
of magicians or philosophers, we should hear from their mouths sounds not of derision,
but of triumph. Be it so, then; let them laugh at our Scriptures; let them laugh as much as
they can, when they see themselves daily becoming fewer in number, while some are removed
by death, and others by their embracing the Christian faith, and when all those things are
being fulfilled which were predicted by the prophets who long ago laughed at them, and
said that they would fight and bark against the truth in vain, and would gradually come over
to our side; and who not only transmitted these statements to us, their descendants, for our
learning, but promised that they should be fulfilled in our experience.
33. It is neither unreasonable nor unprofitable to inquire what these miracles signify,
so that, after their significance has been explained, men may believe not only that they really
occurred, but also that they have been recorded, because of their possessing symbolical
meaning. Let him, therefore, who proposes to inquire why the prophet Jonah was three days
in the capacious belly of a sea monster, begin by dismissing doubts as to the fact itself; for
this did actually occur, and did not occur in vain. For if figures which are expressed in words
923
To Deogratias