16. The judges said: Convertibility translates the person whom it befalls into another;
as, for example, we might say that if a Jew were to make up his mind to become a Christian,
or, on the other hand, if a Christian were to decide to be a Gentile, this would be a species
of convertibility, and a cause of the same.1590 But, again, if we suppose a Gentile to keep by
all his own heathen properties, and to offer sacrifices to his gods, and to do service to the
temples as usual, surely you would not be of opinion that he could be said to be converted,
while he yet holds by his properties, and goes on in them? What, then, do you say? Do they
sustain convertibility or not? And as Manes hesitated, Archelaus proceeded thus: If, indeed,
he says that both natures are convertible,1591 what is there to prevent our thinking them to
be one and the same object? For if they are inconvertible, then surely in natures which are
similarly inconvertible and similarly unbegotten there is no distinction, neither can the one
of them be recognised as good or as evil. But if they are both convertible, then, forsooth, the
possible result may be both that the good is made evil, and that the evil is made good. If,
however, this is the possible result, why should we not speak of one only as unbegotten,1592
which would be a conception in worthier accordance with the reckoning of truth? For we
have to consider how that evil one became so at first, or against what objects he exercised
his wickedness before the formation of the world. When the heavens had not yet appeared,
when the earth did not yet subsist, and when there was neither man nor animal, against
whom did he put his wickedness in operation? whom did he oppress unjustly? whom did
he rob and kill? But if you say that he first appeared in his evil nature to his own kin,1593
then without doubt you give the proof that he comes of a good nature. And if, again, all
these are also evil, how can Satan then cast out Satan?1594 But while thus reduced to a di-
lemma on this point, you may change your position in the discussion, and say that the good
suffered violence from the evil. But none the more is it without peril for you to make such
a statement, to the effect of affirming the vanquishing of the light; for what is vanquished
has destruction near it.1595 For what says the divine word? “Who can enter into a strong
man’s house, and spoil his goods, except he be stronger than he?”1596 But if you allege that
1590 The text runs thus: “ut si dicamus, Judæus, si velit fieri Christianus, aut si Christianus velit esse gentilis,
hæc species est convertibilitatis et causa.”
1591 The text gives convertibiles. Routh suggests inconvertibiles, inconvertible.
1592 The text is unum dicamus ingenitum. Routh suggests unum bonum, etc. = Why should we not speak of
only one unbegotten good?
1593 The text is, “quod si suis eum dicas extitisse malum, sine dubio ergo ostenditur illum bonæ esse naturæ.”
Routh suggests, “quia istis suis adversatur qui mali sunt,” etc. = The fact that he is adverse to those who are of
his own kin, and who are evil, would be a proof that he comes of a good nature.
1594 Mark iii. 23.
1595 Or, kin to it, vicinum habet interitum.
1596 Mark iii. 27.
Chapter XVI.
445
Chapter XVI.