it may escape the sneers of cavilling hearers. Scripture informs us that the Deity proceeded
by a sort of graduated and ordered advance to the creation of man. After the foundations
of the universe were laid, as the history records, man did not appear on the earth at once;
but the creation of the brutes preceded his, and the plants preceded them. Thereby Scripture
shows that the vital forces blended with the world of matter according to a gradation; first,
it infused itself into insensate nature; and in continuation of this advanced into the sentient
world; and then ascended to intelligent and rational beings. Accordingly, while all existing
things must be either corporeal or spiritual, the former are divided into the animate and
inanimate. By animate, I mean possessed of life: and of the things possessed of life, some
have it with sensation, the rest have no sensation. Again, of these sentient things, some have
reason, the rest have not. Seeing, then, that this life of sensation could not possibly exist
apart from the matter which is the subject of it, and the intellectual life could not be embod-
ied, either, without growing in the sentient, on this account the creation of man is related
as coming last, as of one who took up into himself every single form of life, both that of
plants and that which is seen in brutes. His nourishment and growth he derives from veget-
able life; for even in vegetables such processes are to be seen when aliment is being drawn
in by their roots and given off in fruit and leaves. His sentient organization he derives from
the brute creation. But his faculty of thought and reason is incommunicable1799, and is a
peculiar gift in our nature, to be considered by itself. However, just as this nature has the
instinct acquisitive of the necessaries to material existence—an instinct which, when mani-
fested in us men, we call Appetite—and as we admit this appertains to the vegetable form
of life, since we can notice it there too like so many impulses working naturally to satisfy
themselves with their kindred aliment and to issue in germination, so all the peculiar condi-
tions of the brute creation are blended with the intellectual part of the soul. To them, she
continued, belongs anger; to them belongs fear; to them all those other opposing activities
and hits the truth.” But he immediately asks for Scripture authority. So that this λόγος, though it refers to
Genesis, is not yet based upon Scripture. It is a “consecutive” and consistent account of human nature: but it is
virtually identical with that advanced at the end of Book I. of Aristotle’s Ethics. It is a piece of secular theorizing.
The sneers of cavillers may well be deprecated. Consistent, however, with this view of the λόγος here offered by
Macrina, there is another possible meaning in ὡς ἐν γυμνασί& 251·, κ. τ. λ., i.e. “Let us put forward the following
account with all possible care and circumspection, as if we were disputing in the schools; so that cavillers may
have nothing to find fault with”: ὡς ἂν expressing purpose, not a wish. The cavillers will thus refer to sticklers
for Greek method and metaphysics: and Gregory’s congratulation of his sister’s lucidity and grasp of the truth
will be all the more significant.
1799 Following the order and stopping of Krabinger, ἄμικτόν ἐστι καὶ ἰδιάζον ἐπὶ ταύτης τῆς φύσεως, ἐφ᾽
ἑαυτοῦ, κ. τ. λ.
820
On the Soul and the Resurrection.