Chapter XIX.—Objections from the Revelation and the First Epistle of St. John Refuted.
But how far (are we to treat) of Paul; since even John appears to give some secret
countenance to the opposite side? as if in the Apocalypse he has manifestly assigned to for-
nication the auxiliary aid of repentance, where, to the angel of the Thyatirenes, the Spirit
sends a message that He “hath against him that he kept (in communion) the woman Jezebel,
who calleth herself a prophet, and teacheth, 932 and seduceth my servants unto fornicating
and eating of idol sacrifice. And I gave her bounteously a space of time, that she might enter
upon repentance; nor is she willing to enter upon it on the count of fornication. Behold, I
will give her into a bed, and her adulterers with herself into greatest pressure, unless they
shall have repented of her works.” 933 I am content with the fact that, between apostles,
there is a common agreement in rules of faith and of discipline. For, “Whether (it be) I,”
says (Paul), “or they, thus we preach.” 934 Accordingly, it is material to the interest of the
whole sacrament to believe nothing conceded by John, which has been flatly refused by
Paul. This harmony of the Holy Spirit whoever observes, shall by Him be conducted into
His meanings. For (the angel of the Thyatirene Church) was secretly introducing into the
Church, and urging justly to repentance, an heretical woman, who had taken upon herself
to teach what she had learnt from the Nicolaitans. For who has a doubt that an heretic,
deceived by (a spurious baptismal) rite, upon discovering his mischance, and expiating it
by repentance, both attains pardon and is restored to the bosom of the Church? Whence
even among us, as being on a par with an heathen, nay even more than heathen, an heretic
likewise, (such an one) is purged through the baptism of truth from each character, 935 and
admitted (to the Church). Or else, if you are certain that that woman had, after a living
faith, subsequently expired, and turned heretic, in order that you may claim pardon as the
result of repentance, not as it were for an heretical, but as it were for a believing, sinner: let
her, I grant, repent; but with the view of ceasing from adultery, not however in the prospect
of restoration (to Church-fellowship) as well. For this will be a repentance which we, too,
acknowledge to be due much more (than you do); but which we reserve, for pardon, to God.
936
In short, this Apocalypse, in its later passages, has assigned “the infamous and fornicat-
ors,” as well as “the cowardly, and unbelieving, and murderers, and sorcerers, and idolaters,”
who have been guilty of any such crime while professing the faith, to “the lake of fire,” 937
932 Or, “saith and teacheth that she is a prophet.”
933 Rev. ii. 18, 20–22.
934 1 Cor. xv. 11.
935 i.e., of heathen and heretic.
936 See the end of the foregoing chapter.
937 Rev. xxi. 8.
Objections from the Revelation and the First Epistle of St. John Refuted.
215
Objections from the Revelation and the First Epistle of St. John Refute…