JAMES CRICHTON OF ELIOCK
elusive evidence as to these two Crichtons being totally distinct
persons is furnished by Bernardino Baldini,
1
a contemporary
Milanese author, who addresses to James Crichton, whom he
designates
" the survivor," some verses, in which, referring to
the Admirable Crichton, he bestows high praise upon " thy
kinsman," and Crichton the Survivor fittingly acknowledges the
compliment to his relation in lines addressed to Baldini. The
latter has more than one eulogium to lay at the feet of the first
and more celebrated James in this work.
If there were not in existence these various documents, one
would feel inclined to regard the whole story of his career as
pure romance ; but there is a large mass of contemporary
evidence—which is the best we can have—in his favour.
His letters, it must be confessed, are not altogether pleasant
reading. Although the epistolary style of the period frequently
degenerated into gross flattery, one would have preferred less of
the servility and superlative praise which Crichton too often
expresses in these letters. As far as present investigations show,
he has not left any writings of outstanding merit ; but that does
not mean that he had not considerable knowledge and great
natural gifts. We have no complete record of his life and
works, and it is impossible to say what may have been lost in the
centuries that have passed since he dazzled the courts and palaces
of Italy by oratory and action and mnemonic powers which won
for him, even in his own brief lifetime (if we accept the state-
ment alone of Bishop Zibramonti) world-wide fame. What
makes it so difficult for us to estimate his real worth to-day is the
fact that his celebrity was largely the result of the impressions
he made on the minds of his contemporaries as orator, philo-
sopher, theologian, linguist, courtier, and gentleman of arms.
That Crichton was blessed with endowments of a high order we
1 Bernardini Baldini lusus ad M. Antonium Baldinum fratris filium. Mediolani : ex typ.
P. Pontii, 1586.
361