427
Letter XXI.
St. Ambrose excuses himself for not having gone to the consistory when summoned,
on the ground that in matters of faith no one but bishops could rightly judge, and that he
was not contumacious because he would not suffer wrong to be done to his own order. And
he adds that Auxentius would perhaps choose as judges either Jews or unbelievers, that is,
persons hostile to Christ. He says further that he is willing to discuss the matters in dispute
at a synod, and that he would have told the Emperor by word of mouth what he is now
writing, but that his fellow bishops and the people would not suffer him to do so.
Ambrose, Bishop, to the most gracious Emperor and blessed Augustus, Valentinian.
1. Dalmatius, the tribune and notary, summoned me by the orders of your Clemency,
as he asserted, demanding that I should also choose judges, as Auxentius had done. He did
not mention the names of those who had been asked for, but he added that there was to be
a discussion in the consistory, and that the judgment of your piety would give the decision.
2. To this I make, as I think, a suitable answer. No one ought to consider me contuma-
cious when I affirm what your father of august memory not only replied by word of mouth,53
but also sanctioned by his laws, that, in a matter of faith, or any ecclesiastical ordinance, he
should judge who was not unsuited by office, nor disqualified by equity, for these are the
words of the rescript. That is, it was his desire that priests should judge concerning priests.
Moreover, if a bishop were accused of other matters also, and a question of character was
to be enquired into, it was also his will that this should be reserved for the judgment of
bishops.
3. Who, then, has answered your Clemency contumaciously? He who desires that you
should be like your father, or he that wishes you to be unlike him? Unless, perhaps, the
judgment of so great an Emperor seems to any persons of small account, whose faith has
been proved by the constancy of his profession,54 and his wisdom declared by the continual
improvement of the State.
4. When have you heard, most gracious Emperor, that laymen gave judgment concerning
a bishop in a matter of faith? Are we so prostrate through the flattery of some as to be un-
53 “When Valentinian was journeying from Constantinople to Rome…some bishops despatched Hypatian…to
request permission to assemble themselves together for deliberation on questions of doctrine.…Valentinian
made the following reply: ‘I am but one of the laity, and have therefore no right to interfere in these transactions;
let the priests, to whom such matters appertain, assemble where they please.’” Sozomen, Eccl. Hist. VI. 7 [Vol.
II. of this series]. The law referred to is not extant.
54 Allusion is here made to a celebrated act of Valentinian, when attending on the Emperor Julian at the
temple of Fortune. One of the attendants sprinkled him with lustral water, and Valentinian struck him with his
fist, saying that this water defiled rather than purified those whom it touched. Comp. Sozomen, Hist. Eccl. VI.
6.
Letter XXI: To Valentinian II., Declining Challenge of Auxentius.
913
Letter XXI: To Valentinian II., Declining Challenge of Auxentius.