Chapter 6.—Concerning the Mythic, that Is, the Fabulous, Theology, and the Civil,
Against Varro.
O Marcus Varro! thou art the most acute, and without doubt the most learned, but still
114
a man, not God,—now lifted up by the Spirit of God to see and to announce divine things,
thou seest, indeed, that divine things are to be separated from human trifles and lies, but
thou fearest to offend those most corrupt opinions of the populace, and their customs in
public superstitions, which thou thyself, when thou considerest them on all sides, perceivest,
and all your literature loudly pronounces to be abhorrent from the nature of the gods, even
of such gods as the frailty of the human mind supposes to exist in the elements of this world.
What can the most excellent human talent do here? What can human learning, though
manifold, avail thee in this perplexity? Thou desirest to worship the natural gods; thou art
compelled to worship the civil. Thou hast found some of the gods to be fabulous, on whom
thou vomitest forth very freely what thou thinkest, and, whether thou willest or not, thou
wettest therewith even the civil gods. Thou sayest, forsooth, that the fabulous are adapted
to the theatre, the natural to the world, and the civil to the city; though the world is a divine
work, but cities and theatres are the works of men, and though the gods who are laughed
at in the theatre are not other than those who are adored in the temples; and ye do not ex-
hibit games in honor of other gods than those to whom ye immolate victims. How much
more freely and more subtly wouldst thou have decided these hadst thou said that some
gods are natural, others established by men; and concerning those who have been so estab-
lished, the literature of the poets gives one account, and that of the priests another,—both
of which are, nevertheless, so friendly the one to the other, through fellowship in falsehood,
that they are both pleasing to the demons, to whom the doctrine of the truth is hostile.
That theology, therefore, which they call natural, being put aside for a moment, as it is
afterwards to be discussed, we ask if any one is really content to seek a hope for eternal life
from poetical, theatrical, scenic gods? Perish the thought! The true God avert so wild and
sacrilegious a madness! What, is eternal life to be asked from those gods whom these things
pleased, and whom these things propitiate, in which their own crimes are represented? No
one, as I think, has arrived at such a pitch of headlong and furious impiety. So then, neither
by the fabulous nor by the civil theology does any one obtain eternal life. For the one sows
base things concerning the gods by feigning them, the other reaps by cherishing them; the
one scatters lies, the other gathers them together; the one pursues divine things with false
crimes, the other incorporates among divine things the plays which are made up of these
crimes; the one sounds abroad in human songs impious fictions concerning the gods, the
other consecrates these for the festivities of the gods themselves; the one sings the misdeeds
and crimes of the gods, the other loves them; the one gives forth or feigns, the other either
attests the true or delights in the false. Both are base; both are damnable. But the one which
is theatrical teaches public abomination, and that one which is of the city adorns itself with
Concerning the Mythic, that Is, the Fabulous, Theology, and the Civil, Against Varro.
269
Concerning the Mythic, that Is, the Fabulous, Theology, and the Civil, Against…