Chapter VII.
Against those who assert that it is not proper for “with whom” to be said of the Son, and that
the proper phrase is “through whom.”
16. But their contention is that to use the phrase “with him” is altogether strange and
unusual, while “through him” is at once most familiar in Holy Scripture, and very common
in the language of the brotherhood.817 What is our answer to this? We say, Blessed are the
ears that have not heard you and the hearts that have been kept from the wounds of your
words. To you, on the other hand, who are lovers of Christ,818 I say that the Church recog-
nizes both uses, and deprecates neither as subversive of the other. For whenever we are
contemplating the majesty of the nature of the Only Begotten, and the excellence of His
dignity, we bear witness that the glory is with the Father; while on the other hand, whenever
we bethink us of His bestowal819 on us of good gifts, and of our access820 to, and admission
into, the household of God,821 we confess that this grace is effected for us through Him and
by822Him.
It follows that the one phrase “with whom” is the proper one to be used in the ascription
of glory, while the other, “through whom,” is specially appropriate in giving of thanks. It is
also quite untrue to allege that the phrase “with whom” is unfamiliar in the usage of the
devout. All those whose soundness of character leads them to hold the dignity of antiquity
to be more honourable than mere new-fangled novelty, and who have preserved the tradition
of their fathers823 unadulterated, alike in town and in country, have employed this phrase.
It is, on the contrary, they who are surfeited with the familiar and the customary, and arrog-
antly assail the old as stale, who welcome innovation, just as in dress your lovers of display
always prefer some utter novelty to what is generally worn. So you may even still see that
the language of country folk preserves the ancient fashion, while of these, our cunning ex-
perts824 in logomachy, the language bears the brand of the new philosophy.
817 The word ἀδελφότης is in the New Testament peculiar to S. Peter (1 Peter ii. 17, and v. 9); it occurs in
the Epistle of St. Clement to the Corinthians, Chap. ii.
818 Φιλόχριστοι. The word is not common, but occurs in inscriptions. cf. Anth. Pal. I. x. 13. ὀρθὴν πίστιν
ἔχουσα φιλοχρίστοιο μενοινῆς.
819 χορηγία. cf. the use of the cognate verb in 1 Pet. iv. 11. ἐξ ἰσχύος ἧς χορηγεί ὁ θεός.
820 προσαγωγή. cf. Eph. ii. 18.
821 οἰκείωσιν πρὸς τὸν Θεόν. cf. οἰκεῖοι τοῦ Θεοῦ in Eph. ii. 19.
822 ἐν.
823 cf. Gal. i. 14.
824 The verb, ἐντρίβομαι, appears to be used by St. Basil, if he wrote ἐντετριμμένων in the sense of to be
ἐντριβής or versed in a thing (cf. Soph. Ant. 177)—a sense not illustrated by classical usage. But the reading of
Against those who assert that it is not proper for “with whom” to be said of the Son, and that the proper phrase is “through whom.”
160
Against those who assert that it is not proper for “with whom” to be said…