this grace of hope alone, can properly be called a duty. But it is just as absurd to talk of the
exercises of this holy hope, the strong exercise of this grace of the Spirit, in a carnal, stupid,
careless frame, such a frame yet remaining, as it would be to talk of the strong exercises of
love to God, or heavenly-mindedness, or any other grace, while remaining in such a frame.
It is doubtless proper, earnestly to exhort those who are in such a frame to come out of it,
in and by the strong exercise of every grace; but I should not think it proper to press a man
earnestly to maintain strong hope, notwithstanding the prevailing and continuance of great
carnality and stupidity, which is plainly the case of the people I opposed. For this is plainly
to press people to an unholy hope, to a strong hope which is no christian grace, but strong
and wicked presumption; and the promoting of this has most evidently been the effect of
such a method of dealing with souls in innumerable multitudes of awful instances.
You seem, Sir, to suppose, that God’s manner of dealing with his people, while in a secure
and careless frame, is first to give assurance of their good state while they remain in such a
frame, and to make use of that assurance as a mean to bring them out of such a frame. Here,
again, I must beg leave to differ from you, and to think, that none of the instances or texts
you adduce from Scripture, do at all prove the point. I think it is his manner, first to awaken
their consciences, to bring them to reflect upon themselves, to feel their own calamity which
they have brought upon themselves by so departing from God, by which an end is put to
their carelessness and security, and again earnestly and carefully to seek God’s face before
they find him, and before God restores the comfortable and joyful sense of his favour; and
I think this is abundantly evident both from Scripture and experience. You much insist on
the case of Jonah as a clear instance of the thing you lay down. You observe that he says,
chap. ii. ‘I said I am cast out of thy sight, yet I will look again towards thy holy temple.’ Ver.
5, 7. ‘When my soul fainted within me, I remembered the Lord, and my prayer came in
unto thee, even into thine holy temple.’ You speak of these words as expressing an assurance
of his good state and of God’s favour; (I will not now dispute whether they do or not;) and
you speak of this exercise of assurance, as his practice in an evil frame and in a careless frame;
for he slept securely in the sides of the ship, manifesting dismal security, awful carelessness in
a carnal frame. That Jonah was in a careless secure frame when he was asleep in the sides
of the ship, I do not deny. But, my dear Sir, does that prove that he remained still in a careless
secure frame, when in his heart he said these things in the belly of the fish; does it prove
that he remained careless after he was awakened, and saw the furious storm, and owned it
was the fruit of God’s anger towards him for his sins; and does it prove, that he still remained
careless after the whale had swallowed him, when he seemed to himself to be in the belly of
hell, when the water compassed him about, even to the soul, and, as he says, all God’s waters
and billows passed over him, and he was ready to despair when he went down to the bottoms
of the mountains, was ready to think God had cast him out of his sight, and confined him
in a prison, that he could never escape, when the earth with her bars was about him for ever,
229
CHAPTER XV. Arrival of David Brainerd at Northampton. His sickness and…