possession of the place, he does whatever he listeth, whether it be his pleasure to carry off
the citizens into captivity, or to make a complete destruction of the fortress and its contents,
or whether, on the other hand, it may be his will to grant indulgence to the captured
stronghold on the humble suit of the conquered. What, then, does my opponent here say
to this analogy? Did no adversary substantially—which is as much as to say, designedly—over-
throw the muniment cast up between the two?1650 For in his former statements he has
avouched that the darkness passed without its own limits, and supervened upon the kingdom
of the good God. Who, then, overthrew that munition before the one could thus have crossed
over to the other? For it was impossible for the evil one to find any entrance while the mu-
nition stood fast. Why are you silent? Why do you hesitate, Manichæus? Yet, although you
may hold back, I shall proceed with the task of my own accord. For if we suppose you to
say that God destroyed it, then I have to ask what moved Him in this way to demolish the
very thing which He had Himself previously constructed on account of the importunity of
the wicked one, and for the purpose of preserving the separation between them? In what fit
of passion, or under what sense of injury, did He thus set about contending against Himself?
Or was it that He lusted after some of the possessions of the wicked one? But if none of these
things formed the real cause that led God to destroy those very things which He had con-
structed a long time before with the view of estranging and separating the wicked one from
Him, then it must needs be considered no matter of surprise if God should also have become
delighted with his society;1651 for, on your supposition, the munition which had been set
up with the purpose of securing God against trouble from him, will appear to have been
removed just because now he is to be regarded no more as an enemy, but as a friend. And,
on the other hand, if you aver that the wall was destroyed by the wicked one, tell us then
how it can be possible for the works of the good God to be mastered by the wicked one. For
if that is possible, then the evil nature will be proved to be stronger than God. Furthermore,
how can that being, seeing that he is pure and total darkness, surprise the light and apprehend
it, while the evangelist gives us the testimony that “the light shineth in darkness, and the
darkness comprehended it not?”1652 How is this blind one armed? How does the darkness
fight against the kingdom of light? For even as the creatures of God1653 here cannot take in
1650 The sense is obscure here. The text gives, “non substantia id est proposito adversarius quis dejecit,” etc.
Migne edits the sentence without an interrogation. We adopt the interrogative form with Routh. The idea perhaps
is, Did no adversary with materials such as the kings of earth use, and that is as much as to say also with a de-
terminate plan, overthrow, etc.?
1651 The Codex Casinensis has “nec mirum putandum est consortio,” etc. We read with Routh and others,
si ejus consortio, or quod ejus consortio, etc.
1652 John i. 5.
1653 The text gives simply, sicut enim hæc. Routh suggests hæ.
462
Chapter XXIV.