2506 As we learn from chap. 6, §8, the edict commanding the church officers to be seized and thrown into
prison followed popular uprisings in Melitene and Syria, and if Eusebius is correct, was caused by those outbreaks.
Evidently the Christians were held in some way responsible for those rebellious outbursts (possibly they were
a direct consequence of the first edict), and the natural result of them must have been to make Diocletian realize,
as he had not realized before, that the existence of such a society as the Christian Church within the empire—de-
manding as it did supreme allegiance from its members—was a menace to the state. It was therefore not strange
that what began as a purely political thing, as an attempt to break up a supposed treasonable plot formed by
certain Christian officials, should speedily develop into a religious persecution. The first step in such a persecution
would naturally be the seizure of all church officers (see below, p. 397 sq.). The decrees of which Eusebius speaks
in this paragraph are evidently to be identified with the one mentioned in chap. 6, §8. This being so, it is clear
that Eusebius’ account can lay no claims to chronological order. This must be remembered, or we shall fall into
repeated difficulties in reading this eighth book. We are obliged to arrange the order of events for ourselves, for
his account is quite desultory, and devoid both of logical and chronological sequence. The decrees or writings
(γρ€μματα) mentioned in this paragraph constituted really but one edict (cf. chap. 6, §8), which is known to us
as the Second Edict of Diocletian. Its date cannot be determined with exactness, for, as Mason remarks, it may
have been issued at any time between February and November; but it was probably published not many months
after the first, inasmuch as it was a result of disturbances which arose in consequence of the first. Mason is inclined
to place it in March, within a month after the issue of the first, but that seems to me a little too early. In issuing
the edict Diocletian followed the example of Valerian in part, and yet only in part; for instead of commanding
that the church officers be slain, he commanded only that they be seized. He evidently believed that he could
accomplish his purpose best by getting the leading men of the church into his hands and holding them as hostages,
while denying them the glory of martyrdom (cf. Mason, p. 132 sq.). The persons affected by the edict, according
to Eusebius, were “all the rulers of the churches” (τοὺς τῶν ἐκκλησιῶν προέδρους π€ντας; cf. also Mart. Pal.
Introd., §2). In chap. 6, §8, he says τοὺς πανταχόσε τῶν ἐκκλησιῶν προεστῶτας. These words would seem to
imply that only the bishops were intended, but we learn from Lactantius (De mort. pers. 15) that presbyters and
other officers (presbyteri ac ministri) were included, and this is confirmed, as Mason remarks (p. 133, note), by
the sequel. We must therefore take the words used by Eusebius in the general sense of “church officers.” According
to Lactantius, their families suffered with them (cum omnibus suis deducebantur), but Eusebius says nothing of
that.
2507 We learn from Lactantius (l.c.) that the officers of the church, under the terms of the second edict, were
thrown into prison without any option being given them in the matter of sacrificing. They were not asked to
sacrifice, but were imprisoned unconditionally. This was so far in agreement with Valerian’s edict, which had
decreed the instant death of all church officers without the option of sacrificing. But as Eusebius tells us here,
they were afterwards called upon to sacrifice, and as he tells us in the first paragraph of the next chapter, multitudes
yielded, and that of course meant their release, as indeed we are directly told in chap. 6, §10. We may gather
from the present passage and from the other passages referred to, taken in connection with the second chapter
of the Martyrs of Palestine, that this decree, ordaining their release on condition of sacrificing, was issued on
the occasion of Diocletian’s Vicennalia, which were celebrated in December, 303, on the twentieth anniversary
of the death of Carus, which Diocletian reckoned as the beginning of his reign, though he was not in reality
835
The Destruction of the Churches.