Hast thou killed] Hast thou not feared to kill? He is said to kill, First, In that he was the first occasion thereof. Secondly, in that, as is probable, he knew the whole carriage. Thirdly, in that he punished not the actors thereof. Fourthly, in that he approved and ratified it by taking possession. and also] Was it not enough to take away his life, but that thou must also alienate the inheritance from the family, against Gods law? See v. 2. dogs licked] Or, like as the dogs. This was accomplished in Ahab, chap. 22. 38. and in his Song of Solomon, 2 King. 9. 25, 26. Malefactours blood being spilt on the ground, dogs that came by used to lick it up.