Chapter XXV.—The Divine Scriptures that are accepted and those that are not.778
778 This chapter is the only place in which Eusebius attempts to treat the canon systematically, and in it he
is speaking purely as an historian, not as a critic. He is endeavoring to give an accurate statement of the general
opinion of the orthodox Church of his day in regard to the number and names of its sacred books. He does not,
in this passage, apply to the various works any criterion of canonicity further than their acceptance as canonical
by the orthodox Church. He simply records the state of the canon; he does not endeavor to form a canon. He
has nothing to do, therefore, with the nature and origin of the books which the church accepts. As remarked by
Weiss (Einleitung in das N. T., p. 96), the influence of Eusebius in the formation of the canon is very commonly
overestimated. He contributed himself very little; his office was to record the usage of the church of his age, not
to mould it. The church whose judgment he takes is, in the main, the church of the Orient, and in that church
at this time all the works which we now call canonical (and only those) were already commonly accepted, or
were becoming more and more widely accepted as such. From the standpoint, then, of canonicity, Eusebius divided
the works which he mentions in this chapter into two classes: the canonical (including the Homologoumena and
the Antilogomena) and the uncanonical (including the νόθοι and the ἀναπλ€σματα αὶρετικῶν ἀνδρῶν). But
the νόθοι he connects much more closely with the Homologoumena and Antilegomena than with the heretical
works, which are, in fact, separated from all the rest and placed in a class by themselves. What, then, is the relation
of the Homologoumena, Antilegomena, and νόθοι to each other, as Eusebius classifies them? The crucial point
is the relation of the νόθοι to the ἀντιλεγόμενα. Lücke (Ueber den N. T. Kanon des Eusebius, p. 11 sq.) identified
the two, but such identification is impossible in this passage. The passages which he cites to confirm his view
prove only that the word Antilegomena is commonly employed by Eusebius in a general sense to include all
disputed works, and therefore, of course, the νόθοι also; that is, the term Antilegomena is ordinarily used, not
as identical with νόθοι, but as inclusive of it. This, however, establishes nothing as to Eusebius’ technical use of
the words in the present passage, where he is endeavoring to draw close distinctions. Various views have been
taken since Lücke’s time upon the relation of these terms to each other in this connection; but, to me at least,
none of them seem satisfactory, and I have been led to adopt the following simple explanation. The Antilegomena,
in the narrower sense peculiar to this summary, were works which, in Eusebius’ day, were, as he believed,
commonly accepted by the Eastern Church as canonical, but which, nevertheless, as he well knew, had not always
been thus accepted, and, indeed, were not even then universally accepted as such. The tendency, however, was
distinctly in the direction of their ever-wider acceptance. On the other hand, the νόθοιwere works which, although
they had been used by the Fathers and were quoted as γραφὴ by some of them, were, at this time, not acknow-
ledged as canonical. Although perhaps not universally rejected from the canon, yet they were commonly so re-
jected, and the tendency was distinctly in the direction of their ever-wider rejection. Whatever their merit, and
whatever their antiquity and their claims to authenticity, Eusebius could not place them among the canonical
books. The term νόθοι, then, in this passage, must not be taken, as it commonly is, to mean spurious or unau-
thentic, but to mean uncanonical. It is in this sense, as against the canonical Homologoumena and Antilegomena,
that Eusebius, as I believe, uses it here, and his use of it in this sense is perfectly legitimate. In using it he passes
no judgment upon the authenticity of the works referred to; that, in the present case, is not his concern. As an
historian he observed tendencies, and judged accordingly. He saw that the authority of the Antilegomena was
The Divine Scriptures that are accepted and those that are not.
321
The Divine Scriptures that are accepted and those that are not.