D UO OR T.
ARGUMENT.
ARNOBIUS now attacks the heathen mythology, pointing out that such
deities as Piety, Concord, Safety, and the like, could only be mere
abstractions (1, 2); while, as to many others, it would be difficult to
suppose—especially when facts are compared with theories—that they
were seriously spoken of as deities, e.g. Luperca, Preestana, Pantica (3),
and Pellonia (4); the sinister deities (5); Lateranus, a god degraded
to the kitchen (6); and others to whom were assigned obscene and
trifling offices (7); and asking whether the existence of these deities
depended on the things for which they cared, or the performance of
the offices over which they were set, and how, if they were first in
the order of existence, they could be named from things which did
not then exist, and how their names were known (8). Common-sense
will not allow us to believe in gods of Gain, Lust, Money, and the rest
(9); and besides, we could not stop here, for if there were gods to pre-
side over bones, honey, thresholds, we should find it impossible to deny
that everywhere and for everything there are special gods (10). What
proof, it is asked, do the gods give of their existence? do they appear
when invoked? do they give true oracles (11)? how were they made
known to men, and how could it be certain that some one did not take
the place of all those supposed to be present at different rites (12)?
Arnobius next goes on to point out that several deities were spoken of
under one name, while, on the contrary, several names were sometimes
applied to one deity (13) ; e.g. there were three Jupiters, five Suns and
Mercuries, five Minervas (14), four Vulcans, three Dianas and 7Esculapii,
six called Hercules, and four called Venus, and others, in like manner,
from which would arise much confusion (15); for if Minerva were in-
— voked, the five might be supposed to appear, each claiming the honour
of deity as her own, in which case the position of the worshipper would
be one of danger and perplexity (16). The others might be similarly
referred to, and this alone would make it impossible to believe in these
deities (17). And if it should be said that these writings are false, it
might be answered that it is only of such published statements that
notice could be taken; and that, if they were discredited, this fact
* should be made evident; and, finally, that from them all the religious
\ ideas of the heathen were drawn (18). In saying that a god was
183