18
is before all ages, since even before he was generated in energy, He was in virtue with the
Father ingenerately, the Father being always Father, as King always and Saviour always,
having all things in virtue, and being always in the same respects and in the same way. This
we have been forced to transmit to you, Beloved, as making clear to you the deliberation of
our inquiry and assent, and how reasonably we resisted even to the last minute, as long as
we were offended at statements which differed from our own, but received without contention
what no longer pained us, as soon as, on a candid examination of the sense of the words,
they appeared to us to coincide with what we ourselves have professed in the faith which
we have already published.”3
It will be seen that while the expressions “of the substance of the Father,” “begotten not
made,” and “One in substance,” or “consubstantial with the Father,” are all explicitly anti-
Arianistic, yet none of them contradicts the doctrines held by Eusebius before the Council,
so far as we can learn them from his epistles to Alexander and Euphration and from the
Cæsarean creed. His own explanation of those expressions, which it is to be observed was
the explanation given by the Council itself, and which therefore he was fully warranted in
accepting,—even though it may not have been so rigid as to satisfy an Athanasius,—shows
us how this is. He had believed before that the Son partook of the Godhood in very truth,
that He was “begotten,” and therefore “not made,” if “made” implied something different
from “begotten,” as the Nicene Fathers held that it did; and he had believed before that the
“Son of God has no resemblance to created’ things, but is in every respect like the Father
only who begat him, and that He is of no other substance or essence than the Father,” and
therefore if that was what the word “Consubstantial” (ὁμοούσιος) meant he could not do
otherwise than accept that too.
It is clear that the dread of Sabellianism was still before the eyes of Eusebius, and was
the cause of his hesitation in assenting to the various changes, especially to the use of the
word ὁμοούσιος, which had been a Sabellian word and had been rejected on that account
by the Synod of Antioch, at which Paul of Samosata had been condemned some sixty years
before.
It still remains to explain Eusebius’ sanction of the anathemas attached to the creed
which expressly condemn at least one of the beliefs which he had himself formerly held,
viz.: that the “Father was before the Son,” or as he puts it elsewhere, that “He who is begat
him who was not.” The knot might of course be simply cut by supposing an act of hypocrisy
on his part, but the writer is convinced that such a conclusion does violence to all that we
know of Eusebius and of his subsequent treatment of the questions involved in this discussion.
It is quite possible to suppose that a real change of opinion on his part took place during
3 The translation is that of Newman, as given in the Oxford edition of Athanasius’ Select Treatises against
Arianism, p. 59 sq.
29
The Outbreak of the Arian Controversy. The Attitude of Eusebius.