in a night vision, the above-mentioned Alexander, who was then bishop of another parish.1823
257
2. Thereupon, as by Divine direction, he journeyed from the land of Cappadocia, where
he first held the episcopate, to Jerusalem, in consequence of a vow and for the sake of in-
formation in regard to its places.1824 They received him there with great cordiality, and
would not permit him to return, because of another revelation seen by them at night, which
uttered the clearest message to the most zealous among them. For it made known that if
they would go outside the gates, they would receive the bishop foreordained for them by
God. And having done this, with the unanimous consent of the bishops of the neighboring
churches, they constrained him to remain.
3. Alexander, himself, in private letters to the Antinoites,1825 which are still preserved
among us, mentions the joint episcopate of Narcissus and himself, writing in these words
at the end of the epistle:
40, al. 44 and to Antonianus, Ep. 51, al. 55) that there should be only one bishop in a city, and we see from the
works of various Fathers that this rule was universally accepted at an early date. The eighth canon of Nicæa
refers to this principle in passing as if it were already firmly established, and the council evidently did not think
it necessary to promulgate a special canon on the subject. Because of this principle, Augustine hesitated to allow
himself to be ordained assistant bishop of Hippo; and although his scruples were overcome at the time, he after-
ward, upon learning of the Nicene Canon, considered the practice of having a coadjutor illegal and refused to
ordain one for himself. But, as the instances referred to above and many others show, not all the Church inter-
preted the principle as rigidly as Augustine did, and hence under certain circumstances exceptions were made
to the rule, and were looked upon throughout the Church as quite lawful. The existence of two bishops in one
city as a matter of compromise, for the sake of healing a schism, formed one common exception to the general
principle (see Bingham, II. 13. 2), and the appointment of coadjutors, as in the present case, formed another.
1823 Of what city in Cappadocia Alexander was bishop we are not told by Eusebius, nor by our other ancient
authorities. Valesius (note on this passage) and Tillemont (Hist. eccles. III. p. 415) give Flaviopolis or Flaviadis
as the name of the city (upon the authority of Basilicon, Jur. Græco-Rom. Tom. I. p. 295, according to Tillemont).
But Flaviopolis was a city of Cilicia, and hence Tillemont conjectures that it had once been taken from Cappadocia
and attached to Cilicia, and that its inhabitants retained the memory of Alexander, their early bishop. The report
seems to rest upon a very slender foundation; but not having access to the authority cited, I am unable to form
an opinion as to the worth of the tradition.
1824 εὐχῆς καὶ τῶν τόπων ἱστορίας ἕνεκεν.
1825 ᾽Αντινόεια (Antinoë or Antinoöpolis) was a city of Egypt founded by Hadrian in honor of Antinous
(see Bk. IV. chap. 8, note 3). This is the first mention of a church there, but its bishops were present at more
than one council in later centuries (see Wiltsch’s Geography and Statistics, p. 59, 196, 473). This letter must have
been written between 212, at about which time Alexander became Narcissus’ coadjutor (see chap. 8, note 6),
and 216, when Origen visited Palestine (see chap. 19, note 23). For at the time of that visit Alexander is said to
have been bishop of Jerusalem, and no mention is made of Narcissus, who must therefore have been already
623
Alexander.