365
Excursus on the Marriage of the Clergy.
On this subject there is a popular misconception which must first be removed. In the
popular mind to-day there is no distinction between “a married clergy” being allowed, and
“the marriage of the clergy” being allowed; even theological writers who have attained some
repute have confused these two things in the most unfortunate and perplexing fashion. It
will suffice to mention as an instance of this Bp. Harold Browne in his book on the XXXIX.
Articles, in which not only is the confusion above spoken of made, but the very blunder is
used for controversial purposes, to back up and support by the authority of the ancient
Church in the East (which allowed a married clergy) the practice of the Nestorians and of
the modern Church of England, both of which tolerate the marriage of the clergy, a thing
which the ancient Church abhorred and punished with deposition.
I cannot better express the doctrine and practice of the ancient Church in the East than
by quoting the words of the Rev. John Fulton in the Introduction to the Third Edition of
his Index Canonum.345 He says: “Marriage was no impediment to ordination even as a
Bishop; and Bishops, Priests, and Deacons, equally with other men, were forbidden to put
away their wives under pretext of religion. The case was different when a man was unmarried
at the time of his ordination. Then he was held to have given himself wholly to God in the
office of the Holy Ministry, and he was forbidden to take back from his offering that measure
of his cares and his affections which must necessarily be given to the maintenance and
nurture of his family. In short, the married man might be ordained, but with a few exceptions
no man was allowed to marry after ordination.” In his “Digest” sub voce “Celibacy” he gives
the earliest canon law on the subject as follows: “None of the clergy, except readers and
singers may marry after ordination (Ap. Can. xxvi.); but deacons may marry, if at their or-
dination they have declared an intention to do so (Ancyra x.). A priest who marries is to
be deposed (Neocæsarea i.). A deaconess who marries is to be anathematized (Chal. xv.);
a monk or dedicated virgin who marries, is to be excommunicated (Chal. xvi.). Those who
break their vows of celibacy are to fulfil the penance of digamists (Ancyra xix.).”346
We may then take it for a general principle that in no part of the ancient Church was a
priest allowed to contract holy matrimony; and in no place was he allowed to exercise his
priesthood afterwards, if he should dare to enter into such a relation with a woman. As I
have so often remarked it is not my place to approve or disapprove this law of the Church,
my duty is the much simpler one of tracing historically what the law was and what it is in
the East and West to-day. The Reformers considered that in this, as in most other matters,
these venerable churches had made a mistake, but neither the maintenance nor the disproof
of this opinion in any way concerns me, so far as this volume is concerned. All that is ne-
345 John Fulton, Index Canonum, p. 29 (N.Y., 1892.)
346 Ibid., p. 294.
Excursus on the Marriage of the Clergy.
643
Excursus on the Marriage of the Clergy.