The literary creations of Donatism had been somewhat more fertile than that of Cæ-
cilianism. We must not belittle Donatus the Great, Parmenian, Petilian, Gaudentius, and
certainly the eminence of Tychonius is confessed by Augustin himself. Up to this time
Optatus of Milevis had been the only forcible opponent. But against the great Augustin
whom could they bring into the field? And against the great Augustin, backed by the energy
of the State, there was little hope of fairness. Augustin found a new and weighty school.
Donatism, with its impossible ideal, already began to despise the culture which seemed to
help its defeat and withdrew into its sensitive shell after the manner of all puristic tendencies
under persecution.
The two prevalent lines of attack are the historical on the origin of the schism, which
involved the dissection of the documents, and the doctrinal, or the discussion of the true
notes of the Church from the basis of the Scriptures. This latter Augustin preferred, because
final; he bowed to no patristic. One or the other or both may be traced in all his works,
great or small, against them. Out of so protracted a controversy there grew up a symmetrical
and comprehensive theory of the Church and the Sacraments on either side.
Of three fundamental points of Donatism, as perpetuated practices of North Africa,
rebaptism and the encouragement of a martyr spirit with its attendant feasts, the continuance
of the Seniores in the government of the Church, we find Augustin aiming mainly at the
overthrow of the first two. One of his earliest letters suggests to his bishop some means for
checking the drunkenness and great excess connected with the Natalitia. Passing to the
specific subject in view:
In the early period of his presbyterate, (possibly about 392, others place it later), Augustin
journeyed through Mutugenna, which apparently belonged to his bishop’s see. He learned
how pacifically disposed Maximin, Donatist bishop of Sinaita, was. The friendly feeling
374
thus kindled toward him was shaken by the rumor that he had rebaptized a defecting
Catholic deacon of Mutugenna; not willing to credit the story, he visited the deacon’s home.
His parents testified to their son’s reception into the same office by the Donatists. In the
absence of Bishop Valerius, he writes to Maximin with entreaty, refusing to credit the repe-
tition of the rite, and urging him to remain firm in the convictions which had been imputed
to him. He solicits a reply, that both letters may be read in the public service, after the dis-
mission of the military. The prominent points of the letter are: while declining to recognize
the validity of Maximin’s orders, he does not refuse to salute him as Dominus dulcissimus,
and Pater venerabilis. His solicitude as a shepherd to do his duty to all the sheep, constrains
him to force himself upon their attention, and to be eager for correspondence or conference
with a view to bringing them back to the fold. He is perfectly assured of the absolute and
final correctness of his idea of the Church, and of the hopeless error of Donatism, an error
so great as to merit eternal destruction. He discriminates, however, between heresy and
schism at this time. Rebaptism in any case is a sin, but as applied to apostatizing Catholics,
649
An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.